Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Design detection in SETI — just fine; design detection in biology — no way!

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Skeptics, ever selective in their skepticism, remain convinced that SETI (the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) is a legitimate scientific program. But applying methods of design detection to biology — well that’s just plain stupid. See Robert Camp’s piece here.

Design from biology fairly smacks us over the head. What about design from SETI (i.e., convincing proof of alien intelligence)? We’re still waiting for a shred of evidence — in this regard Michael Crichton hit the nail on the head: http://www.crichton-official.com/speeches/speeches_quote04.html.

Comments
SETI vs SIDI From my limited but painful experience with Information Theory, I would estimate that SETI is excellent science. The SETI analytics are exactly that which would detect intelligently designed signals. My less limited and more painful experiences with post-modernism suggests the reason why SETI is doomed to failure: they are looking for exactly the wrong phenomena. SETI is motivated by Methodological Naturalism (Neo-monism in a cheap gorilla suit). Steven Hawkings offers a classic expression of this doctrine: "We are such insignificant creatures on a minor planet of a very average star in the outer suburb of one of a hundred billion galaxies. So it is difficult to believe in a God that would care about us or even notice our existence." Neo-darwinist apologetics dictate that there then must be more evolved species everywhere in the universe, with more advanced SETIs, and all we have to do is listen. The evidence is mounting that there is something amiss with the SETI approach. One of the french fries is missing from the Happy Meal. SIDI (Search for Intelligent Design Information) based on ID apologetics, would take an Intron-early (like, first-cause early) approach, and look for linguistic (prescribed) phenomena in genomic data. Policital Science question: What impact would the sucess of SIDI over SETI have on Genetic Patents in an Information based economy?Collin DuCrâne
June 1, 2006
June
06
Jun
1
01
2006
10:26 AM
10
10
26
AM
PDT
1 2 3

Leave a Reply