We can’t help you.
Sign noted in a computer guy’s office somewhere in North America: If after ten minutes at the poker table you do not know who the patsy is—you are the patsy.
First, what exactly is Darwin’s theory anyway, other than an invite to the approved parties?
Here it is: Information can be created without intelligence. That is, natural selection acting on random mutation explains the order of life we see all around us. What can’t survive won’t, and that explains how very complex life forms and structures — including the human mind — get built up.
True: Things that can’t survive don’t. But why would that fact alone drive nature to produce anything as simple as a kitten, let alone a math genius?
We’ve looked earlier at documented ways evolution can really happen — if all we really want to know is how life forms can change over time. That said, I spent the last fifteen years trying to understand the cultural part.
Darwinism isn’t just about evolution as such. It is also a way of looking at life. It tries to explain life without assuming that there is any actual mind at all, dispensing with traditional philosophies and religions.
Humans are assumed to do what they do because they are guided by their instincts, in the same way that nature haphazardly produces a kitten or a math genius.
Ideas have consequences. Think of that when, for example, an elaborately coiffed* person on prime time TV announces … [blather re some politician’s views on “evolution”] More.
Don’t let it get any worse. See also: Talk to the fossils: Let’s see what they say back
It wasn’t ID that made Darwinism a bad idea. It was a bad idea to begin with.
But profitable for certain lobbies, of course.
* Are you paying, via some publicly funded broadcasting program, for the Darwin fretgirl’s hairdos? Be sure to tune in for that at least. It’s all you’ll get.
If you are stuck funding Darwin in failing school systems, well, as we search for solutions out of the mess … do you by any chance live in a free country? Check that out; some people do live in free countries, apparently.
Note: No more news blogging till tonight, due to O’Leary for News’ alternate day job.
Darwin fretgirl?
“Humans are assumed to do what they do because they are guided by their instincts”
Humans are guided by their prejudices, which is slightly different than their instincts. It is not possible to actually understand most wars until you learn the prejudices of the guys who agreed to order their underlings to start killing each other. That is, both sides need to have leaders with odd understandings of the current reality in order to have a war. If only one of the sides can’t deal with real reality, the other side can often figure out some deal short of war.
As near as I can tell, politics is the same. It’s just harder to find books that explain the odd workings of the minds of men who are merely screwing up a city somewhere instead of getting a million humans killed in a war.
Note that the Libertarians point out that the arrival of “government” CAUSES wars and crime. This is because prior to the government exercising the SOLE legal power of armed coercion, the 2 sides sorted things out as equals. Once a territorial governor shows up, there is someone you can bribe to support your position with marshals and judges and such. Armed resistance is then the only alternative to elimination.
//off-topic//
From whence cometh the coordination?
I’m just asking …
“… the need to coordinate literally millions of biochemical events …”
WHAT IS DOING THE COORDINATING?
The coordinators, obviously. They are a rather secretive cult though.
And who coordinates the coordinators? 🙂
The controllers control the coordinators.
The almost infinite computing capacity of random mutation was acquired randomly; an elegant conciliation and a most propitious dispensation of random providence.
Coordination is random mutation’s middle name. I think an initial looks better. Random C Mutation (although not of this parish, as, no doubt, Private Eye would add). Some have greatness thrust upon them. I’m afraid we shall just have to sit this one out.
God does indeed has a rival to be reckoned with.
Ok we don’t know what really controls stuff in the cell. DNA has some “control”, but is in turn controlled by various epigenetic factors; and so forth.
But I’m willing to overlook all that.
What I want to know is what could possibly coordinate trillions of cells. Obviously not DNA or epigenetic factors in individual cells, since they are being coordinated. Is there even a concept of something that has the adult form of a complex multicellular organism in ‘mind’ AND has the capability and power to direct en instruct trillions of cells? Is there even a candidate?
Sure there is intercellular communication, but without instruction from a higher level what else than “I’m a muscle cell” can a muscle cell say to other cells? And how is that useful information to other cells? “There is a muscle cell next to me. Well that’s good to know, because now I know what to do.”
No, you don’t know what to do mr. Neighbour Cell, because you don’t have the map of the adult form in mind and even if you did you wouldn’t know what your position is.
follow-up #8
—
In case anyone wants to talk about Hox-genes ….