Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

The Google Problem

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The reason we have been excluded from Google’s index is several mirror sites that automatically copy and republish our content have sprung up. In the past there was only one such mirror site which is Wesley Elsberry’s at

http://antievolution.org/buud/

To address this I am going to post a copyright message at the bottom of our webpage saying that all content here is copyright and may not be reproduced without permission. I will then explicitely warn Wesley Elsberry and other mirrors that they are in violation of the law and will copy the warning mail to the abuse address of their respective ISPs that I expect the violations to end immediately.

I will also undertake the task of modifying our blog software so that a brief copyright message is included on all articles and all comments so that automatic republishing will also reproduce the copyright notice.

If that doesn’t work I will discuss with Professor Dembski the possibility of prosecution. Since one cannot draw blood from a turnip this may or may not be financially advisable although the thought of bankrupting Wesley Elsberry is appealing enough in its own right so that I may underwrite that personally just for the principle.

As well, I have tentatively prepared the following for a reinclusion request with Google

Several websites not under our control have mirrored our content without our permission. We are a blog with strictly enforced moderation rules for commenters. These other websites are mirroring our content so that they may comment on it without moderation.

This has been going on for some time with the website antievolution.org being the only mirror I knew of at http://antievolution.org/buud/

These sites are using RSS feeds to mirror us.

I was unaware that their abuse of RSS feeds could cause us to be in violation of Google quality guidelines.

I think it’s unfair to our many legitimate users of RSS feeds to disable RSS. I have in the past considered using IP blocks to disable the mirrors but determined that some of the sites have dynamic IPs which would require me to block whole domains which would also include legitimate users of those domains. Also, with antievolution.org were I to IP block it we would no longer be able to use trackbacks with pandasthumb.com because it is on the same server IP as antievolution.org.

Here is what I have now done to comply with Google Quality Guidelines:

1) added IP blocks to known mirror sites
2) disabled rss feeds
3) added explicit copyright messages to all our content and reported violations as abuse to the ISP hosting the mirror sites

It is my hope that once the mirrors have been shut down I will be able to lift the IP blocks and reenable RSS feeds. Once again I wish to stress it is not the fault or intent or wish that uncommondescent’s content be duplicated.

Wesley, I know this will reach you. You are hereby explicitely put on notice that BUUD is illegally republishing our content which is protected by implicit copyright already and your actions have caused substantial real damages to uncommondescent.com, its owners, and content contributors. You will shut down BUUD immediately to ameliorate these damages.

Comments
Well, that was fast. Wesley has password protected antievolution.org/buudDaveScot
September 21, 2006
September
09
Sep
21
21
2006
10:29 AM
10
10
29
AM
PDT
I filed a reinclusion request with Google and explained the situation to them as follows:
Several websites are duplicating our content via RSS feeds without our permission. One we are aware of is antievolution.org/buud This is in violation of Google Quality guidelines as it duplicates our content in other domains. We failed to publish copyright notices on our blog to discourage this practice. We have taken the following corrective actions: 1) Added a prominent copyright notice on our blog header. 2) Installed a plugin that automatically appends copyright notices to all RSS feeds as follows: Copyright © 2006 Uncommon Descent. This Feed is for personal non-commercial use only. If you are not reading this material in your news aggregator, the site you are looking at is guilty of copyright infringement. Please contact legal@uncommondescent.com so we can take legal action immediately. . 3) Created an email address legal@uncommondescent.com so we may be notified when this happens. If the above is not sufficient we are prepared to take additional actions as necessary including but not limited to: a) legal action for copyright infringement b) IP blocks on the offending websites c) disabling RSS feeds d) notifying the ISP of the offenders that a client is infringing our copyrights Some of the websites are using dynamic IPs that would require us to block whole domains. We wish to not do that as it may block innocents from our blog. We also consider disabling all RSS feeds as a very last resort.
DaveScot
September 21, 2006
September
09
Sep
21
21
2006
10:02 AM
10
10
02
AM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply