Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

BREAKING/DEVELOPING: Russia invades Ukraine

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email
Wikipedia initial map of the invasion, especially note a reported incursion from western Belarus and the main weight of reported bombings and incursions in the eastern trans-Dnieper region, the DonBass

BBC announces:

Russian forces have launched a military assault on neighbouring Ukraine, crossing its borders and bombing military targets near big cities.

A residential building in Chuguev was destroyed after it was shelled.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has warned that Moscow’s response will be “instant” if anyone tries to take on Russia.

Ukraine has urged the UN “to do everything possible” to stop what it says is a full-scale war.

We could title this, the geostrategic price of weakness, starting with the USA. Recall here, my 2016 framework:

Of course as this seems overnight the fog of war is very much in effect and we need to bear in mind that we are unlikely to have a full or reliable picture. DEVELOPING, UPDATES TO FOLLOW

U/D Feb 25, a map of the course of the invasion:

Wikipedia’s updated but provisional map c Feb 24, showing reported lines of thrust. Note, provisional

U/D Feb 27: Wiki Map Feb 26

Wiki map c Feb 26, showing lodgement areas, thrusts and move to decapitate by taking Kiev

U/D Feb 28, let’s insert the Feb 28 Wiki map to compare:

U/D Feb 27: HT Daily Mail, a map of detail fighting near Kiev:

HT, Daily Mail, on fighting near Kiev. Seizing an airport as an air head is a known standard modern tactic for the side with air superiority. Compare Bagram in Afghanistan and its abandonment just before the US fleeing from Afghanistan

U/D, Feb 27: Geostrategic considerations:

U/D Feb 28, Putin puts nuke forces to high alert, issues implied threats, even as he agrees to talks — vid:

U/D Mar 1: Overnight on the updated operational situation map at Wikipedia:

Update overnight Feb 28/Mar 1. We see a bridgehead across the Dnieper in the South coming from Crimea, with a column advancing NW. To the N, a cluster of breakouts on the E bank are beginning to fan out and another is joining with the enclave to the E. Other columns are pushing in from the N and E, and the siege of Kharkov and Kiev are also underway. Air strikes cluster on Kiev but are spread across the whole country.

U/D, March 3: The already taken zones are being consolidated and extended and columns are surging out. Most notably, from Crimea to the West, and the thrust to Kiev is being broadened.

U/D Mar 4: VDH analyses, pivoting on the Javelin anti-tank missile:

U/D March 5, map is revised on Mar 3rd:

Notice here fresh probes from White Russia, a thrust to the W along a major road net towards Poland, a swing back towards Kiev for a thrust that was apparently aiming to pinch off a chunk of Northern Ukraine continued columns from the NE and the continuation of the western breakout from Crimea. Kiev and Kharkov seem to be holding,

U/D2 Mar 5, a Daily Mail Map:

This Daily Mail map is more outline and differs in details but tells the same basic story.

U/D May 8, a screen shot from Russian TV with a marked up encirclement in the E:

Oh yes, apparently there is an enemies list:

  • All EU member States,
  • The USA
  • Australia
  • Albania
  • Andorra
  • Czech Republic
  • Great Britain (including Jersey, Anguilla, British Virgin Islands and Gibraltar)
  • Iceland
  • Canada
  • Liechtenstein
  • Micronesia
  • Monaco
  • New Zealand
  • Norway
  • Republic of Korea
  • San Marino
  • North Macedonia
  • Singapore
  • Taiwan
  • Ukraine
  • Montenegro
  • Switzerland
  • Japan

They left off a raft of UK OT’s there, including Cayman, Montserrat, Turks and Caicos Islands, Bermuda, Isle of Man, Falklands, Pitcairn, St Helena, South Georgia etc. I guess they list where their offshore accounts are and got frozen?

U/D March 9, Putin in Southern Africa as a trainer for guerilla leaders, 1973:

This is my comment on an iHarare piece brought to my attention by people inclined to cheer on anything that is suggested as aiding liberation from Western Imperialism. An objection was made in the combox, that Putin’s age would be 20-ish and his official life story puts him in law school at relevant times. I noted that he was KGB and we can expect contradictory narratives, where the window is that in which military service is likely. The association with two African Presidents of the left is noteworthy. I suggest, assume it is not in fact Putin, that would only lead to, Russians were engaged in geostrategic pushes in guise of liberation movements, some of which have proved disastrous for ordinary people in certain African countries. The geostrategic point remains.

U/D: Wiki map, March 6, showing armoured thrusts far beyond the zones identified in a Russian proposal for ceasefire terms. Notice, these are by and large conservative relative to what has been shown on Russian TV, scroll up:

U/D, Mar 15 – 20: Russian forces consolidate while keeping Kiev under pressure:

The consolidation ratchets up pressure on Ukraine, the attacks on the capital can lead to decision, negotiations seem stalled over Russia’s demand for neutrality, which has already been seen as invitation to invasion. Sanctions have been put in place but are seldom decisive.

Comments
F/N: More from Col Bay: https://www.strategypage.com/on_point/20220302151226.aspx
Former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice told Fox News Putin employs "an ever-deepening, delusional rendering of history ... always a kind of victimology" and that "he is descending into something I haven't personally seen before." That's serious deterioration. Perhaps we've physical clues. Instead of the hard cheeks and macho chest (see Putin the Stud photos circa 2008), doctors note Vlad 2022's cheeks puff like a man taking steroids. Weaponized speculation: Does he suffer from terminal cancer? With his time running out, he ignites a war to achieve his obsession? Shades of Greek drama, but the poets are dramatizing tragedy wrought by obsessed human beings. Time and again obsessed, powerful despots seize the bloody initiative, pursuing empire or Lebensraum nach Osten or a global caliphate. These destructive actors perpetually scourge humanity. I personally believe Putin is delusional and his delusions have spurred insanity. For years I've seen the former KGB colonel as a cunning, calculating, disciplined and narcissistic fanatic driven by a vision of the Russian empire reborn. He seeks to control the core components of the Romanov empire and the Soviet Union: Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and Khazakstan -- the RUBK as I've called it since the late 1990s. RUBK, like Rubik's Cube, a puzzle Putin swears to solve and piece together with the force of his will, no matter the desire of others. Now the force of his will is expressed by dropping cluster bombs on Ukrainian neighborhoods. A dispute persists over the precise translation of Putin's April 25, 2005, lamentation over the demise of the Soviet Union. Did he say that the USSR's demise was "a major geopolitical disaster of the (20th) century" or that it was the "greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the century"? The BBC and NBC News chose "catastrophe." Both translations confirm the USSR's collapse appalled Putin. Definitely a scarred psyche, though twisted psyche and soul seem more apt. Putin suffers two historical ills: revanchism and irredentism. By mobilizing Russian ethnonational sentiments, Putin intends to recover what he regards as lost territories (irredenta) that by God and by history (or myth) belong to Mother Russia. Moreover, outsiders (the U.S., NATO) seek to deny Mother Russia what is Hers. Since the mid-1990s these tropes and claims of Russian victimhood have fired Putin's propaganda. He propagandized his own people. claiming he must act to protect "cut off" Russians and secure "Russian rights" in lost regions (former Soviet territories). He invoked these justifications in 2008 during the Russo-Georgia War. In Russian Army military exercises from around 2016 on the enemy was called "The Western Coalition," deliberately incriminating NATO. Agreed, Putin doesn't act alone. Russian Army generals and Putin's coterie of billionaire Russian oligarchs encouraged his delusions or at least failed to curb them. No one wants to be the naysayer who tells the obsessed leader he can't achieve his goals. The generals and oligarchs signed off on fighting the slow war of attrition Russia has waged in Ukraine since 2014. Vlad did succeed in annexing Crimea. Ukraine, however, continues to resist the conventional invasion Putin launched in February. Why escalate to tanks and air attacks and airborne assaults? Why gamble now? Is the terminal illness plot something other than my fiction? A fact: Antiwar protests, many led by the parents of Russian conscript soldiers, have occurred in over 30 Russian cities. Russian oligarchs and mafiya types value their money. Sanctions will ultimately squeeze oligarch accounts and even seize laundered cash. Britain and other countries are moving to seize real estate assets owned by Russian oligarchs. Denying Russia's banks market access has already trashed the ruble. Oligarchs must choose between their money and Putin.
A sobering analysis of a major bad actor on the world stage. Bay goes on to suggest, "[t]he way out for the oligarchs is a Kremlin coup toppling Putin." Unfortunately, the example of the July 1944 plot against Hitler shows the riskiness of such a move. The question is, can he be censured or deemed credibly unfit and removed for cause? Lawless oligarchy, sadly, is historically the natural state of government. And the signs of descent to such much closer to home should give us pause. Putin's case is only one among many across the years of grim reading we need to learn from. KFkairosfocus
March 3, 2022
March
03
Mar
3
03
2022
09:41 PM
9
09
41
PM
PDT
U/D: Extending to W and E coming from Crimea, broadening the thrust towards Kiev, pushing columns beyond Kiev to the West. The offensive continues.kairosfocus
March 3, 2022
March
03
Mar
3
03
2022
09:00 AM
9
09
00
AM
PDT
Long discussion by foreign policy people on what caused this. Some will be repeats. https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1498491107902062592.htmljerry
March 3, 2022
March
03
Mar
3
03
2022
04:04 AM
4
04
04
AM
PDT
Coincidence? https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Energy/Taiwan-hit-by-widespread-power-outagesLieutenant Commander Data
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
08:08 PM
8
08
08
PM
PDT
Senior Russian Official :US Uses Ukraine As Ploy to Weaken Europe
William J Murray Here’s what I’ve found to be a pretty good rule of thumb: if the mainstream media is painting someone out to be the villain of the story, it’s highly likely they’re actually closer to being the hero of the story.
:lol: Trump talked about HCQ. What happens next? HCQ used for 40 years and one of the safest medicine "become" overnight very dangerous because were billions of vaccines waiting in warehouses . They need fake studies? No problem. The Lancet retracted later but has played its role to start the vaccine clown-show. Would have been a loss of trillions $ for some people . MSM is not what we think it is . It's a PsyOp tool. Who own it mold the perception for people who watch it .Lieutenant Commander Data
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
01:40 PM
1
01
40
PM
PDT
WJM, while the Russian young man reflects the geostrategic perspective in the vid in the OP, he starts with NATO as aggressor. As for NATO membership moving Eastwards, guess why Poland, Hungary, Estonia etc think they need a defensive umbrella given what has been playing out in the Ukraine. When it sounds like Finland and Sweden are thinking that way, it says a lot. Yes, the US is such these days that many are distinctly cool towards it; that is all but irrelevant to Russia's realpolitik. What is needed is a fundamentally different approach. KFkairosfocus
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
11:55 AM
11
11
55
AM
PDT
Two other perspectives on Ukraine.
Why John Mearsheimer Blames the U.S. for the Crisis in Ukraine
https://www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/why-john-mearsheimer-blames-the-us-for-the-crisis-in-ukraine
The West’s Green Delusions Empowered Putin
https://bariweiss.substack.com/p/the-wests-green-delusions-empowered?s=rjerry
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
09:48 AM
9
09
48
AM
PDT
Here's what I've found to be a pretty good rule of thumb: if the mainstream media is painting someone out to be the villain of the story, it's highly likely they're actually closer to being the hero of the story.William J Murray
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
07:43 AM
7
07
43
AM
PDT
An entirely different perspective on what is going on in the Ukraine: https://vid8.poal.co/user/AOU/m78pTCFWilliam J Murray
March 2, 2022
March
03
Mar
2
02
2022
07:30 AM
7
07
30
AM
PDT
Gas prices were headed down before the virus hit even as the economy was expanding. They were $2.40 gal just before the virus hit. They were $1.74 six weeks later and back at $2.40 when Biden took over. They are now at $3.60 per gal or a 50% increase since Biden started restrictions on drilling and a crack down on pipe lines. Hard not to attribute this rise to Biden and his policies. https://www.gasbuddy.com/charts Fracking is what caused gasoline prices to drop in an expanding economy 2014-2016. If anything the Democrats have restricted drilling and fracking. Prices were in the $3.75-$3.90 range for most of the early Obama years until the fracking oil started flooding the market. Natural gas prices are roughly double that before the virus. Again probably due to restrictions on fracking. https://www.macrotrends.net/2478/natural-gas-prices-historical-chartjerry
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
03:18 PM
3
03
18
PM
PDT
Sev, a geostrategic explanation is anything but a justification. Unfortunately, such considerations are often predictive of patterns of conflict. KFkairosfocus
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
03:02 PM
3
03
02
PM
PDT
As of 9:17 a.m. ET on Wednesday, which is Inauguration Day for President-elect Joe Biden, WTI Crude was up 1.53 percent at $53.77, and Brent Crude prices were trading above $56 a barrel—up by 1.16 percent at $56.52, very close to the 11-month high prices hit last week. Today oil is at $106, really all I need to know. Joe Biden is doing what he promised “destroy the fossil fuel industry. Vividvividbleau
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
03:02 PM
3
03
02
PM
PDT
Off topic but I wonder what the over under is on how many times we will here this phrase after Biden’s SOTU “ Biden gave the speech of his life” Vividvividbleau
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
02:44 PM
2
02
44
PM
PDT
Bizarre exchange showing ideological lensing https://legalinsurrection.com/2022/02/small-twitter-account-upstages-nikole-hannah-jones-after-her-bizarre-ukraine-hot-take/kairosfocus
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
02:42 PM
2
02
42
PM
PDT
Another point of view on the ineptness of US and Ukrainian politicians in the last 30 years.
Ukraine’s Deadly Gamble By tying itself to a reckless and dangerous America, the Ukrainians made a blunder that client states will study for years to come
Did the bogus impeachment of Trump over a telephone conversation lead to Ukraine’s downfall.
In order to cover up for what the Bidens and perhaps other senior Obama officials had done in Ukraine, a Democratic Congress impeached Trump for trying to figure out what American policymakers had been doing in Ukraine over the past decade. As for the Ukrainians, they again put themselves in the middle of it, when they should have stayed home. The end result was that the Ukrainians had helped weaken an American president who, unlike Obama, gave them arms to defend themselves against the Russians. More seriously, they reinforced Putin’s view that, especially in partnership with the Democrats, Ukraine did not understand its true place in the world as a buffer state—and would continue to allow themselves to be used as an instrument by policymakers whose combination of narcissism and fecklessness made them particularly prone to dangerous miscalculations. The 2020 election victory of Joe Biden, a man whose family had been paid by the Ukrainians to protect them, can have done little to quiet Putin’s sense that Ukraine needed to be put in its place before it was used yet again as a weapon against him. From the perspective of the U.S. national security establishment, Biden’s victory over Trump signaled that its actions in Ukraine would stay hidden. So long as the media continued to bark that the 45th president of the United States is Putin’s stooge, no one would be held accountable for anything. Except, as it turns out, D.C. political operatives aren’t the only people who can make history. Putin can, too. And the people of Ukraine will come out much the worse for both of their efforts.
https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/ukraines-deadly-gamblejerry
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
02:15 PM
2
02
15
PM
PDT
It's confusing. This Forbes article - Is The U.S. Energy Independent? goes into a bit more detail.Seversky
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
02:07 PM
2
02
07
PM
PDT
Oopsy! This conversation has aged really really well. :lol: Nuland-Pyatt leaked phone conversation Changing of regime in Ukraine by US (Biden involved and rewarded by Ukraine indirectly through his son-Burisma, etc. ) is allowed but when Putin try to change the regime is bad ? :lol: https://consortiumnews.com/2014/02/23/neocons-and-the-ukraine-coup/Lieutenant Commander Data
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
02:03 PM
2
02
03
PM
PDT
Sev What changed? From Wiki “In early December 2018, it was reported that the US had turned into a net exporter of oil "last week", thus breaking nearly 75 continuous years of dependence on foreign oil. Reportedly, the US sold overseas a net of 211,000 barrels a day of crude and refined products such as gasoline and diesel. This, compared to net imports of about three million barrels a day on average previously during 2018 and the prior annual peak of more than 12 million barrels a day during 2005, was confirmed by the US Energy Information Administration.[34]” Vividvividbleau
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
01:50 PM
1
01
50
PM
PDT
I have to agree. There's something very wrong there. On the other hand, are we prepared to put up with higher gas prices in order to make the sanctions bite?Seversky
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
01:33 PM
1
01
33
PM
PDT
If true this is so sick. “Think about the madness of this… Joe Biden is running around trying to look tough, hitting Russia with sanctions over Vladimir Putin’s obscene invasion of Ukraine. But at the same time, we pay Russia in the vicinity of $70 million per day for oil imports. In other words, during these seven days of Putin’s criminal war against Ukraine, we’ve sent this same Putin during those same seven days close to a half-billion dollars!” Vividvividbleau
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
01:08 PM
1
01
08
PM
PDT
None of which justifies what is happening now.Seversky
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
11:53 AM
11
11
53
AM
PDT
Jerry, scroll up and watch the video on the geostrategic issues. Russia lost [2]7 millions or so fighting after June 22, 1941. That's living memory. Ukraine and White Russia are the Western buffers for Russia (used to be Poland under the Czars). There is indeed a long list of key resources in the Ukraine or off its shores, including oil and gas, but that is not all. Then, there is the sealing off of the canal that used to bring water to the Crimea, after 2014. And so forth. KFkairosfocus
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
09:25 AM
9
09
25
AM
PDT
It has nothing to do with oil.
Is oil behind this?
https://redstate.com/streiff/2022/02/27/did-a-quickly-deleted-essay-in-russian-media-explain-what-vladimir-putin-wants-russia-to-gain-from-the-ukraine-invasion-n529150 It has to do with Greater Russia and personal pride in one’ strong bloodline. Does that mean Putin is a racist? For another take - it’s all about NATO. https://peterbeinart.substack.com/p/bidens-cia-director-doesnt-believe?utm_source=url And Victor Davis Hanson always sound logic and judgment which will be ignored. https://amgreatness.com/2022/02/27/the-crowded-road-to-kyiv/jerry
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
07:02 AM
7
07
02
AM
PDT
Viral videos about Russia-Ukraine war that are...fake. What a shock! :lol: https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/many-viral-ukraine-war-videos-flooding-social-media-are-fakeLieutenant Commander Data
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
06:42 AM
6
06
42
AM
PDT
Is oil behind this? https://mobile.twitter.com/JackPosobiec/status/1498533088560824320 If that’s so, why not make Joe look good. That would argue it’s something other than oil. Will the geographic map look different after the conflict but the trade remain the same. In 100 years the Germans went from aspiring world conquerors to irresponsible bean counters and bureaucrats.jerry
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
05:58 AM
5
05
58
AM
PDT
Unverified news from a source from Mar-a-Lago: "Putin and Trump have been in contact since the operation started. "Putin said to Trump that the biolab on Snake Island had been involved in researching a weaponized type of airborne rabies that, if aerosolized, could have ravaged the earth with nearly a 100% mortality rate." “He assured Trump he’d taken precautions to guarantee all pathogens were hit hard and effective enough to render them inert. He wouldn’t say if he used thermobaric ordnance, but that seems a likely possibility,” our source said." “Make no mistake, President Trump. We’re not hitting cities. If we were, more than one building in Kyiv would be hit, and there’d be no electricity, no water, no nothing. We’re burning the trash,” Putin purportedly told Trump. Putin said he have incriminating evidences about the many biological labs . https://realrawnews.com/2022/02/putin-tells-trump-were-burning-the-trash-biolaboratories-destroyed/Lieutenant Commander Data
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
05:39 AM
5
05
39
AM
PDT
U/D: Overnight, as can be seen in the latest map, the situation is far graver as breakout columns and a bridgehead over the Dnieper coming from Crimea indicate. The Crimean and Donbass enclaves now seem to have connected through columns. Ukraine is losing its coast and is ripe for dismemberment even if a prolonged siege of Kiev and Kharkov are in prospect. As of now the Russians have broken out in notoriously classic tank country. Unless the Ukrainians have reserve tank forces positioned to pinch off the columns [as von Manstein did in Feb 1943], they are in serious trouble. KFkairosfocus
March 1, 2022
March
03
Mar
1
01
2022
03:40 AM
3
03
40
AM
PDT
LCD, war in urban areas almost inevitably involves civilian deaths and destruction, there will be abuses and even crimes. The issue is restraint and maintenance of disciplined order. There is not a moral equivalency here. Russia has legitimate security interests that could easily have been secured otherwise. KFkairosfocus
February 28, 2022
February
02
Feb
28
28
2022
09:22 PM
9
09
22
PM
PDT
This you won't hear about in mainstream media: https://twitter.com/emeriticus/status/1498290623232856064?cxt=HHwWgMC-gcbY_8opAAAA PS: All Americans saw MSM PsyOp over Trump how in the world there is a single one who still believe what MSM spit?Lieutenant Commander Data
February 28, 2022
February
02
Feb
28
28
2022
05:43 PM
5
05
43
PM
PDT
Sev
Motivation and morale are much more important factors in war than many people realize. They can’t make up for overwhelming material and numerical superiority but they can go a long way.
A good example of that is the Afghani army which is almost always out manned and out gunned but they have an intense and fearless drive to defend their homeland against invasion. As you say, the will to win is a factor that is not often considered, but it can be the most decisive one.Silver Asiatic
February 28, 2022
February
02
Feb
28
28
2022
03:04 PM
3
03
04
PM
PDT
1 3 4 5 6 7 9

Leave a Reply