Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Darwin lobby’s attack site for Expelled movie a yawner

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

What is the cultural significance of the sheer dullness of National Center for Science Education’s Expelled attack site?

Is this their idea of an attack site?

Rows and rows of links to the usual suspects who have every reason not to like the film’s message, offering the usual denials and denunciations.

Maybe an Expelled philanthropist should give them a grant to spice it up. After all, their site will be no use for Expelled publicity unless they come up with something better.

But wait … maybe they can’t come up with something better. Does that mean they are losing the culture war?

Also:

Will Expelled succeed at the box office?

Expelled: Intellectual property vs. intellectual territorialism

Wanted: Social scientist to study Expelled release

Comments
Does anyone know when the movie will be released in Canada?teleologist_
April 15, 2008
April
04
Apr
15
15
2008
05:02 PM
5
05
02
PM
PDT
Re: "Will Expelled succeed at the box office?" Actually, the chart at Hollywood Stock Exchange is starting to look bullish.jstanley01
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
01:34 PM
1
01
34
PM
PDT
AOFM: “IT’S A COOKBOOK!” LOLOLOLOLOLOL And it hits the nail on the head.tribune7
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
11:25 AM
11
11
25
AM
PDT
angryoldfatman : "IT’S A COOKBOOK!" I love it. One of my fav TZ episodes!Borne
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
11:08 AM
11
11
08
AM
PDT
Well said nullasulus. I didn't give it that much time. I just read some of Colorado CONFIDENTIAL(!) and got halfway down the page and read this:
This [The lack of a quote from Of Pandas and People] seems a curious omission in a movie seeking to poke holes in evolutionary theory and by doing so establish some scientific credentials for ID.
The major source of publicizing this movie have been AFAIK, Ben Stein's tour of the talk market. I can't ever remember Stein giving that as his angle. The movie's title is Expelled, it's clearly more about schools than ID. And everything that I've heard from Stein is about the bias in academia. If the NCSE is going to host a site "exposing" Expelled, don't you think they should do better quality control and pick commentators who can actually follow the plot? That's enough for me. That's their top link and that's the depth of comprehension of their "lead" story. Ridiculous.jjcassidy
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
11:00 AM
11
11
00
AM
PDT
IT’S A COOKBOOK!
LMAO. Well played. (That is one of my favorite episodes and is usually the one I use to introduce people to the show.)Atom
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
10:30 AM
10
10
30
AM
PDT
DaveScot wrote:
How about doing a short piece on man serving science vs. science serving man?
IT'S A COOKBOOK!angryoldfatman
April 13, 2008
April
04
Apr
13
13
2008
08:36 AM
8
08
36
AM
PDT
Actually, they said they were going to unveil a whole design for the site on the 16th. If they had the courage of their convictions they'd let it evolve. Solely by random mutations and natural selection.tribune7
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
06:19 PM
6
06
19
PM
PDT
National Center for Science Education I wonder how many trusting souls thing the National Center for Science Education is a government agency or one sanctioned by the government. I think Dembski should change the name of his site from Design Inference to the National Center for Design Inference.tribune7
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
06:17 PM
6
06
17
PM
PDT
At # 12 Yes, some have. Anyway, I'm not sure what you mean by "quote-mine".DeepDesign
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
03:51 PM
3
03
51
PM
PDT
(Thanks, DaveScot. Glad your radar is switched on.)Lutepisc
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
03:39 PM
3
03
39
PM
PDT
DD I’ve been visiting this sight since the spring of 2006. Some people have been pointing this out all along. People have been pointing out all along you've been visiting this site since 2006? Sorry, the quote-mine devil made me do it...DaveScot
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
03:31 PM
3
03
31
PM
PDT
Denyse re; sit above the salt Perfect.DaveScot
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
03:27 PM
3
03
27
PM
PDT
Great observations, nullasalus! (But Gawd, sometimes I think there are more sock puppets than legitimate posters on this site. :-(Lutepisc
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
03:23 PM
3
03
23
PM
PDT
"The ID guys should be among the traditional Christians' culture heroes. If they are not, tacit adoption of the elite culture's materialism is the likely explanation." I've been visiting this sight since the spring of 2006. Some people have been pointing this out all along.DeepDesign
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
02:17 PM
2
02
17
PM
PDT
I guess all the average person can do is go see the movie (try to go opening weekend) and hope for the best.DeepDesign
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
01:59 PM
1
01
59
PM
PDT
I think they could use some actually persuasive information on there, period. I just browsed the site to see what the criticism is (I haven't seen the movie yet, myself) - "laughable" comes to mind. Just about every link is 'Intelligent design is creationism! Did you know some people who were paid for their interviews are angry that they're in this movie? I don't think Ben Stein is very funny!' Talk about shooting blanks. Engage the movie on its points, be level-headed and fair, and all should be well. Unless the movie has a point after all, and being level-headed and fair is running second place compared to some other goal.nullasalus
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
01:24 PM
1
01
24
PM
PDT
They are most certainly in a war against culture. Whether or not they are loosing I don't know, though I think they are loosing this battle. A lot of bumblers, too. It is possible, for example, that while trying to out and "Sternberg" an animator from Vancouver, the evolanders stumbled upon one of the persons behind Age of the Machine--the video they were all praising as being pro-evolander. Just a heads up, I wrote about it today in Dog coincidence. Have fun.William Wallace
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
01:23 PM
1
01
23
PM
PDT
Yawner is the right word. They need less scientists and a few more writers and graphic designers.poachy
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
01:18 PM
1
01
18
PM
PDT
Actually, they said they were going to unveil a whole design for the site on the 16th. Shouldn't we try not to direct traffic to their site or get their site showing up higher on google? They said their plan is to make it so if someone searches for Expelled on Google, their site is the first to show up.Marie
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
12:45 PM
12
12
45
PM
PDT
Perhaps this
The National Center for Science Education will be posting our full response to the Ben Stein movie Expelled on this site on April 15
might give you a clue. Since Dr Scott was disinvited to a prescreening, despite appearing in the film, they will have to shell out an admission fee on April 15, or whenever it gets released, to see and respond to it.Horace_Worblehat
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
12:36 PM
12
12
36
PM
PDT
Actually, Dave, from anything I can tell, the new atheist types think of themselves as a sort of high priesthood of "science." Thus they would serve science and we would serve them. Don't you agree that that makes it much easier to determine who should sit above the salt? "science" - a careful selection from evidence and interpretations thereof that happens to support their views.O'Leary
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
12:20 PM
12
12
20
PM
PDT
Hi Denyse, How about doing a short piece on man serving science vs. science serving man? I think Dick to the Dawk and friends have lost touch with which serves the other. On the social study you mentioned the response to Expelled don't leave out a study in contrasts with Flock of Dodos and Judgement Day. DaveScot
April 12, 2008
April
04
Apr
12
12
2008
11:50 AM
11
11
50
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply