Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Humans and birds evolved different, “sing” alike?

arroba Email
Robin Red Breast Stock Photo
robin/Free Digital Photos

From Eurekalert:

Birds and humans look different, sound different and evolved completely different organs for voice production. But now new research published in Nature Communications reveals that humans and birds use the exact same physical mechanism to make their vocal cords move and thus produce sound.

“Science has known for over 60 years that this mechanism – called the myoelastic-aerodynamic theory, or in short the MEAD mechanism- drives speech and singing in humans. We have now shown that birds use the exact same mechanism to make vocalizations. MEAD might even turn out to be a widespread mechanism in all land-dwelling vertebrates”, says lead author of the paper, Associate Professor Dr. Coen Elemans, Department of Biology, University of Southern Denmark.

The find may or may not “turn out to be a widespread mechanism in all land-dwelling vertebrates.” If it doesn’t, that points out a problem with the icon of common descent, when it comes to understanding evolution. Not the first time, for sure.

According to Elemans the new discovery not only sheds new light on the sophisticated vocal talents of song birds. The discovery is also interesting and useful because it can be paired with the knowledge about another interesting vocal mechanism shared by some birds and humans: The neural mechanisms underlying vocal learning. Both songbirds and humans are not born with the ability to speak or sing, but must learn their language or song by listening to others, a process called vocal imitation learning or simply vocal learning. More.

There may be a relationship between species that depend on vocal learning and those that feature this mechanism. Happy hunting!

Life forms can have the same characteristics without common descent being an obvious explanation. It can be an obvious explanation if the relationship is close enough (tigers, lions, leopards). But not if it comes down to “But they’re both vertebrates!” That’s when we might better look at convergent evolution: Heading toward the same goals rather than descent from a common ancestor. It suggests a different picture of evolution.

See Evolution appears to converge on goals—but in Darwinian terms, is that possible?

Imprinting (birds that learn who to trust by vocal learning):

Follow UD News at Twitter!

I guess we're all theropods then. That's now obvious.....Right? bb
Birds don't have sophisticated vocal talents. they only use their memory more its no big deal to make sounds. Its just about memory ability in birds. AMEN there is a common idea for vocals thus showing a creator with a common blueprint. The more smarter people investigate nature the more, NOT THE LESS, there will be found simple but common mechanisms and means for universal biology. by the way. talking and singing are the same thing. The body/mind does not recognize a difference. People do because we don't notice we sing most of our talk. that is we use tones of voice for most of the understanding in our sentences. singing is just marginally doing it more., or rather stretching our words more to get in a tone of voice. tHis because the words are themselves pieces of tones. Robert Byers
Most mammals have a pair of vocal folds within the larynx. That they push air through them to make noise isn't so extraordinary. The primary mechanism is passive, with the folds opening and closing elastically, the myoelastic-aerodynamic mechanism. There are also examples of active phonation, such as when a cat purrs. Birds don't use the larynx, though, but the syrinx. It's long been thought that birds also used a myoelastic-aerodynamic mechanism, whereby syringeal tissues vibrate as air is forced through, but the empirical evidence was lacking until now. Zachriel
OK, so the million dollar question is: How many other primates have and use MEAD? If the answer is "none", then there is yet another characteristic of humans that could NOT have been inherited from non-human primate ancestors. Oh, and the photo of the ultra-light makes me wonder how many other primates have figured out how to FLY? mahuna

Leave a Reply