Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

The freedom/mind issue surfaces again

First, a happy thanksgiving. Then, while digesting turkey etc, here is something to ponder. One of the underlying issues surrounding the debates over the design inference is the question of responsible, rational freedom as a key facet of intelligent action, as opposed to blind chance and/or mechanical necessity. It has surfaced again, e.g. the WD400 thread. Some time back, this is part of how I posed the issue, emphasising the difference between self-aware responsible freedom and blindly mechanical causal chains used in computing: Even if deluded about circumstances a self-aware being is just that, self-evidently, incorrigibly self-aware. And, a key facet of that self awareness is of responsible, rational freedom. Without which we cannot choose to follow and accept a Read More ›

Teaching about evolution: Here are some people the Darwin lobby can talk to…

We fancy, for the following communications position, Zack Kopplin, that young guy who was freaked because Louisiana schoolteachers needn’t shout Darwindreck at their classes any more*. But as Adam Deen tells us: When I organised evolution conference to debate the topic of Islam and evolution, there was an obscene backlash. We were labelled as deviants by a prominent Wahhabi preacher for merely having such a debate. One of the guest lecturers was even “excommunicated” for seeking to reconcile the scientific perspective with the faith. More. These guys should be way easier to talk to than a Bayou teacher who has read Darwin’s Doubt. And how about the Darwin-in-the-schools lobby’s “aren’t I good?” girls. We’ll draft them to go talk to these Read More ›

New at MercatorNet

O’Leary for News’ night job: Fake reviews, sure… but fake science journals? Bob the Robot’s TED talk: What robots are and aren’t Robot are things we create to develop our ideas. Will artificial intelligence kill our jobs? That depends. Jumbotron, the smartphone is coming to get you! New tech does not extinguish old art forms. It more often changes their role. Live to text? Well, it’s your neck … Driving while “intexticated”? Social media addiction comes, like other addictions, with a free I-deny-I-have-a-problem package. Follow UD News at Twitter!

Design inference: Is it a Neanderthal flute?

From Discover: Holes in a Bone: Flute or Fluke? Many experts believe an approximately 45,000-year-old bear femur could be a flute — the oldest known musical instrument. Ivan Turk discovered the bone in 1995 in Slovenia’s Divje Babe Archaeological Park, among cave deposits containing Neanderthal tools. But is it a hominin-made flute, or just a bone scavenged by ancient hyenas? In Science Smackdown, we let experts argue both sides of the question. More. Readers? Hear a replica played below. See also: The search for our earliest ancestors: signals in the noise and Neanderthal Man: The long-lost relative turns up again, this time with documents Follow UD News at Twitter!

Pond hydra can modify its own genetic program

But then this is the same life form that can reassemble from a small piece, and lose all its neurons but live. Re the latter feat, new findings may shed light: From Science Daily: Champion of regeneration, the freshwater polyp Hydra is capable of reforming a complete individual from any fragment of its body. It is even able to remain alive when all its neurons have disappeared. Researcher the University of Geneva (UNIGE), Switzerland, have discovered how: cells of the epithelial type modify their genetic program by overexpressing a series of genes, among which some are involved in diverse nervous functions. … “Epithelial cells do not possess typical neuronal functions. However, Hydra’s loss of neurogenesis induces epithelial cells to modify Read More ›

Stanford U: Ancient viruses are part of us and we need them

From The Telegraph: The human genome is littered with sequences left behind from long-ago viral infections but now scientists have found the code is still active Now researchers at Stanford University School of Medicine have found that genetic material from a retrovirus called HERV-H is not only active, but is crucial in allowing a fertilised human egg to grow into an embryo. … “What’s really interesting is that these sequences are found only in primates, raising the possibility that their function may have contributed to unique characteristics that distinguish humans from other animals. Let’s back up and be cautious here. For one thing, many primates are not particularly clever, so we need to be much more specific about why it Read More ›

What is information anyway? Some proposed answers

From Casey Luskin’s talk at Evolution News & Views: Information is not always easy to define, but it often involves a measure of degree of randomness. The fundamental intuition behind information is a reduction in possibilities. The more possibilities you rule out, the more information you’ve conveyed. Nature can produce “information” under certain definitions. Intelligent agents also produce information (certain types, at least). As Henry Quastler observed, “The creation of new information is habitually associated with conscious activity.” To put it another way: The reduction in uncertainty could occur by an intelligent agent, or through a physical occurrence. Types of information and example follow. Conclusion To summarize, Information can be understood and defined in different ways. Some are useful for Read More ›

Biochemist Todd Wood on homo Naledi burials

From his blog: On Saturday, November 21, I had the privilege of hearing Zach Throckmorton of Lincoln Memorial University speak on Homo naledi at the Gray Fossil Site just outside of Johnson City, TN. Dr. Throckmorton is an expert on feet, and he was part of the research team that studied the fossils of Homo naledi after they were excavated from the Rising Star Cave. … I was quite struck by his candid discussion of the burial of these creatures. He was careful to note that they preferred the burial hypothesis because they could not find another credible explanation for why the bones would be in that remote chamber. At the same time, he admitted that these hominins not only Read More ›

Scientific method adds new third step

From a Top Rated journal TM: ‘Seek Funding’ Step Added To Scientific Method PARIS—In an effort to modernize the principles and empirical procedures of examining phenomena and advancing humanity’s collective knowledge, the International Council for Science announced Thursday the addition of a “Seek Funding” step to the scientific method. More. The friend who contributed this tip notes, This is what would happen if philosophers of science really looked at the process of science as currently practiced 🙂 A conference in tht? this time, Marseilles? Note: Top Rated journal:   See also: Retraction Watch and If peer review is working, why all the retractions? Follow UD News at Twitter!

Species: Changing Allele Frequencies?

A new study is out here. They were studying epigenetic effects in planaria flatworms. Same planaria, three different “species”-level “heads” were regenerated. Of course, everything must have an “evoltuion-did-it” explanation; so, for the record, here it is: The ease with which a particular shape could be coaxed from a G. dorotocephala worm was proportional to the proximity of the target worm on the evolutionary timeline. The closer the two species were related, the easier it was to effect the change. This observation strengthens the connection to evolutionary history, suggesting that modulation of physiological circuits may be one more tool exploited by evolution to alter animal body plans. However, there is more to mull over: Working with Girardia dorotocephala – free-living Read More ›

Marine animals use previously unknown communication method: Polarised light

Mantis shrimps use it to avoid already occupied hiding places. From ScienceDaily: Researchers from the Queensland Brain Institute at The University of Queensland have uncovered a new form of secret light communication used by marine animals. … Dr Yakir Gagnon, Professor Justin Marshall and colleagues previously showed that mantis shrimp (Gonodactylaceus falcatus) can reflect and detect circular polarising light, an ability extremely rare in nature. Until now, no-one has known what they use it for. The new study shows the shrimp use circular polarisation as a means to covertly advertise their presence to aggressive competitors. “In birds, colour is what we’re familiar with; in the ocean, reef fish display with colour. This is a form of communication we understand. What Read More ›

This just in: One sixth of water bear’s genes are from microbes

From The Atlantic: The toughest animals in the world aren’t bulky elephants, or cold-tolerant penguins, or even the famously durable cockroach. Instead, the champions of durability are endearing microscopic creatures called tardigrades, or water bears. They live everywhere, from the tallest mountains to the deepest oceans, and from hot springs to Antarctic ice. They can even tolerate New York. They cope with these inhospitable environments by transforming into a nigh-indestructible state. Their adorable shuffling gaits cease. Their eight legs curl inwards. Their rotund bodies shrivel up, expelling almost all of their water and becoming a dried barrel called a “tun.” Their metabolism dwindles to near-nothingness—they are practically dead. And in skirting the edge of death, they become incredibly hard to Read More ›

How horizontal gene transfer has shaped the web of life

“using examples of HGT among prokaryotes, between prokaryotes and eukaryotes, and even between multicellular eukaryotes” From Nature Reviews Genetics:, should feature many useful examples: Here’s the abstract: Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is the sharing of genetic material between organisms that are not in a parent–offspring relationship. HGT is a widely recognized mechanism for adaptation in bacteria and archaea. Microbial antibiotic resistance and pathogenicity are often associated with HGT, but the scope of HGT extends far beyond disease-causing organisms. In this Review, we describe how HGT has shaped the web of life using examples of HGT among prokaryotes, between prokaryotes and eukaryotes, and even between multicellular eukaryotes. We discuss replacement and additive HGT, the proposed mechanisms of HGT, selective forces that Read More ›

Life as “self-perpetuating information strings”?

No, we didn’t come up with that phrase but it is certainly worth considering, considering almost all alternatives. If you doubt that, see “Maybe if we throw enough models at the origin of life… some of them will stick?” From Quanta: The polymath Christoph Adami is investigating life’s origins by reimagining living things as self-perpetuating information strings. … Life, he argues, should not be thought of as a chemical event. Instead, it should be thought of as information. The shift in perspective provides a tidy way in which to begin tackling a messy question. In the following interview, Adami defines information as “the ability to make predictions with a likelihood better than chance,” and he says we should think of the Read More ›

Quasars disappeared suddenly- then one reappeared

Quasars. From Scientific American: A dozen quasars in the early universe appear to have shut down in just a few years, baffling astronomers … Last year Stephanie LaMassa from NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (then at Yale University) discovered the greatest change in luminosity ever detected in a quasar. She was digging through data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey when she found that a quasar had dimmed in brightness by a factor of six in just 10 years. Its spectrum changed, too, from that of a classic quasar to a regular galaxy. … There is nothing controversial about the idea that active galactic nuclei can become inactive. What LaMassa and her colleagues doubted was that a quasar could go Read More ›