Eugenie Scott – Uncommon Descent

Creationism Darwinist rhetorical tactics ID Lessons of History Naturalism Philosophy Religion Science

Design Disquisitions: Jeffrey Koperski on Two Bad Ways and Two Good Ways to Attack ID (Part 1): Two Bad Ways

Here’s my new article at Design Disquisitions. Enjoy: In the next two (potentially three) articles I’ll be taking an in-depth look at an excellent paper written by Jeffrey Koperski, a philosopher of science at Saginaw Valley State University. Koperski has written about ID in several publications (1), which I highly recommend, and he takes a balanced Read More…

orthomyxo You made the comment on March 22nd, clearly referring to the whole world (and comparing tothe global impact of flu:... – Darwinian time trees don’t really work
PaV Orthomyxo: Please get your facts correct. I've already corrected you once. The estimate of 27,000 was based on the Chinese... – Darwinian time trees don’t really work
orthomyxo What a cast of characters, ET things vitD could have prevented the pandemic, PaV is unchastended after his prediction 27k... – Darwinian time trees don’t really work
Viola Lee Thank, JVL. I think letting these folks talk among themselves as much as possible is probably for the best. I... – An interview on God and mathematics
polistra It's tempting to speculate that "crossover" critters like this were able to crossover after a dose of HGT. Having a... – Australian lungfish has largest animal genome
JVL Kairosfocus: I have nothing more to say to you about mathematics and morals. Clearly you have not experienced higher level... – An interview on God and mathematics
JVL Viola Lee: Thanks for the encouragement. Love you really!! It's an odd thing . . . I consider myself a... – An interview on God and mathematics
kairosfocus JVL, Let's see, just your first sentence: >>That is not correct.>> - appeal to duty to truth, and also to... – An interview on God and mathematics
Viola Lee Thanks for the encouragement. – An interview on God and mathematics
JVL Viola Lee: Forget it, I say to myself. If you keep repeating it you might believe it one day! – An interview on God and mathematics
JVL Kairosfocus: why a proof, a particular type of warrant? Ans, because we are prone to error so we seek reliable... – An interview on God and mathematics
Viola Lee Forget it, I say to myself. – An interview on God and mathematics
martin_r off topic, but mentioning Retraction Watch, i like this one: "”Definitely embarrassing:” Nobel Laureate retracts non-reproducible paper in Nature journal"... – Why is Retraction Watch not what...
martin_r in regards to genome size, how many of you heard of C-number paradox ? (chromosome-number paradox) ? here is an... – Australian lungfish has largest animal genome
kairosfocus VL, that we can and do use canons of logic and warrant routinely is not at issue [see Copi's textbook... – An interview on God and mathematics
Viola Lee What you don't address is how human beings ares to use those to reach various judgments about real-world situations, and... – An interview on God and mathematics
Viola Lee KF, we accept that! You don't need to repeat it again. – An interview on God and mathematics
kairosfocus VL, sorry, I am not suggesting that someone here questions use of right reason. I am pointing out that we... – An interview on God and mathematics
Viola Lee Hi JVL. KF seems incapable of understanding that no one is questioning the use of right reason. He is very... – An interview on God and mathematics
kairosfocus JVL, I will again highlight how, yet again, your intended objection -- as is true of any reasoning -- inescapably... – An interview on God and mathematics
jerry It’s not clear if it was actually doneThank you for the warning about the study. I was unaware of Fleming's... – BREAKING: President Trump, Mrs Trump &...