Melanie Phillips – Uncommon Descent

Does Darwinism not matter the way it used to?

David Gelernter was NOT flung out on his ear for doubting Darwin. And, how many people much care now what P.Z. Myers thinks? Is ultra-Darwinism past its sell-by date?

Culture Darwinism Intelligent Design

Brit commentator Melanie Phillips weighs in on David Gelernter dumping Darwin

For many intellectuals, it must seem like an agonizing, nasty divorce but Phillips would be well placed to take it in stride.

Bob O'H Martin_r @ 4 - again, this is an A D A P T A T I O N …. why... – Misleading claims about a long running...
Bob O'H We'll see, but to me it sounds like a mechanism of DNA repair. – Human cells write RNA sequences into...
Sandy Pater Kimbridge @Sandy No…. more like how gravity functions to bring hydrogen together to make stars where none existed before.... – Michael Behe on the “purposeful arrangement...
Querius Kairosfocus @8, What you're describing are the evidences of intelligent design, namely fine tuning, fantastic complexity, emergence of novel body... – Jonathan Bartlett: Intelligent Design Is Not...
Querius Lawrence Krauss apparently doesn't understand nothing. Nothing is not space without time. Probability requires time. And space-time is something, not... – Celebrity physicists are in a row...
Querius Not practically. But that's not to say that quantum effects don't manifest in our macro world. Solar fusion, lasers, photosynthesis,... – Can only math solve the mystery...
TAMMIE LEE HAYNES In Science today, the public cant learn the truth. In practical terms, its impossible. As we have seen the leaders... – Why is science reporting so bad?
solemn existence Germaine to the discussion on body plan information, there's a 4 part series on the topic at ID the future.... – Gunter Bechly vs. Joshua Swamidass at...
Seversky Sounds like it might be a way of getting new information into a genome when ID/creationism argued it could only... – Human cells write RNA sequences into...
Seversky I have known science journalists for whom I had the greatest respect. They clearly cared very much about the subject... – Why is science reporting so bad?
ET Doubter, see the first comment. – Misleading claims about a long running...
ET Pater Kimbridge: Which is why I find it best to listen to the consensus of biologists when it comes to... – Michael Behe on the “purposeful arrangement...
mohammadnursyamsu KRock the one thing that matters is, the extent to which the scientists are materialists. There is materialist philosophy, which... – Why science is losing prestige…
mohammadnursyamsu Querius, Ofcourse I know nothing, but I can only call it as I see it, right? And like many, just... – Can only math solve the mystery...
Pater Kimbridge @Martin_r #22 Nope. Engineer. Which is why I find it best to listen to the consensus of biologists when it... – Michael Behe on the “purposeful arrangement...
Pater Kimbridge @Sandy No.... more like how gravity functions to bring hydrogen together to make stars where none existed before. And lava... – Michael Behe on the “purposeful arrangement...
doubter ET@8 Yes, it was a simple case of evolution, but no new complicated mechanism was created. Very little new information.... – Misleading claims about a long running...
ET Martin_r, E coli already had the ability to digest citrate. In the presence of oxygen the gene that codes for... – Misleading claims about a long running...
asauber You can't just blame journalists. You can blame them, but they are just 1/3 of the real story. I haven't... – Why is science reporting so bad?
Querius Mohammadnursyamsu @4, You might want to brush up on recent experiments in quantum mechanics. For example, consider the following: Anton... – Can only math solve the mystery...
polistra Can't blame scientists for this. And in my experience the press releases are usually excellent, often more insightful than the... – Why is science reporting so bad?