Sino-Tibetan – Uncommon Descent

Intelligent Design language

Did the Sino-Tibetan language family originate over 7000 years ago?

What we don’t know is how language itself arises. Not at all. Every human group already speaks a language.

jawa The three Nobel Prize awards in physics this year are related to the structure of the universe. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2020/penrose/facts/ Physics, like... – John Sanford and James Tour discuss...
William J Murray BA77 said: If ETs really exist, it should be overwhelming evidence that no one could doubt. Isn't this a version... – Space aliens - if we can...
ET bornagain77: Darwinism and Hinduism overlap in fundamental ways. For instance. ‘Aryan master race’, (which the Nazis ‘religiously’ believed in), was... – Space aliens - if we can...
ET More NASA astronauts weigh in Then there are a number of pilots with verified sightings. – Space aliens - if we can...
ET bornagain77: If ETs really exist, it should be overwhelming evidence that no one could doubt. That doesn't follow. There is... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray A more succinct geometrical phrasing occurs to me. I understand that the CMBR information puts the Earth at the center... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77 @49, When trying to explain something to someone who doesn't understand how what you said makes your case, cutting... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77 @46 said: Well WJM, actually, as Paul James-Griffiths explained in his video, there is a materialistic element to Hinduism... – Space aliens - if we can...
Sandy @ET UFO , ETs are part of mind control. I've red somewhere a doc where UFO effect was an option... – Space aliens - if we can...
bornagain77 WJM,,, Unless “large scale structure of the universe” refers to something other than the CMBR data, You are kidding right??... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77, Unless "large scale structure of the universe" refers to something other than the CMBR data, repeating it doesn't change... – Space aliens - if we can...
polistra Well, it's not quite that straightforward. Tourette tics are often complex behaviors and complex sentences that carry meaning. Schizies (and... – Why, as a neurosurgeon, Michael Egnor...
bornagain77 WJM. I've repeated the large scale structure of the universe numerous times now as the piece of the puzzle that... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77 @42, Unless the CMBR provides more than a plane as the identifier of Earth's preferential location, #2 cannot be... – Space aliens - if we can...
bornagain77 Well WJM, actually, as Paul James-Griffiths explained in his video, there is a materialistic element to Hinduism to go along... – Space aliens - if we can...
bornagain77 ET, well, although you may find pagan sources to be credible, I certainly consider pagan sources to be false. And... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77, You can certainly draw evolution from Hindu sources - their whole thing is basically about the evolution of the... – Space aliens - if we can...
bornagain77 WJM, 1 true. 2. false. Again, the large scale structure of the universe drives the nail in the coffin on... – Space aliens - if we can...
ET I call it as it is. You refuse to read the relevant documents. That is the very definition of willful... – Space aliens - if we can...
William J Murray BA77, But you're not answer my simple yes/no questions that will unambiguously let me know if I am interpreting the... – Space aliens - if we can...
bornagain77 Well ET, you certainly are not going to win any points with me by simply calling me 'willfully ignorant'. You... – Space aliens - if we can...