Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

BREAKING/DEVELOPING: Russia invades Ukraine

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email
Wikipedia initial map of the invasion, especially note a reported incursion from western Belarus and the main weight of reported bombings and incursions in the eastern trans-Dnieper region, the DonBass

BBC announces:

Russian forces have launched a military assault on neighbouring Ukraine, crossing its borders and bombing military targets near big cities.

A residential building in Chuguev was destroyed after it was shelled.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has warned that Moscow’s response will be “instant” if anyone tries to take on Russia.

Ukraine has urged the UN “to do everything possible” to stop what it says is a full-scale war.

We could title this, the geostrategic price of weakness, starting with the USA. Recall here, my 2016 framework:

Of course as this seems overnight the fog of war is very much in effect and we need to bear in mind that we are unlikely to have a full or reliable picture. DEVELOPING, UPDATES TO FOLLOW

U/D Feb 25, a map of the course of the invasion:

Wikipedia’s updated but provisional map c Feb 24, showing reported lines of thrust. Note, provisional

U/D Feb 27: Wiki Map Feb 26

Wiki map c Feb 26, showing lodgement areas, thrusts and move to decapitate by taking Kiev

U/D Feb 28, let’s insert the Feb 28 Wiki map to compare:

U/D Feb 27: HT Daily Mail, a map of detail fighting near Kiev:

HT, Daily Mail, on fighting near Kiev. Seizing an airport as an air head is a known standard modern tactic for the side with air superiority. Compare Bagram in Afghanistan and its abandonment just before the US fleeing from Afghanistan

U/D, Feb 27: Geostrategic considerations:

U/D Feb 28, Putin puts nuke forces to high alert, issues implied threats, even as he agrees to talks — vid:

U/D Mar 1: Overnight on the updated operational situation map at Wikipedia:

Update overnight Feb 28/Mar 1. We see a bridgehead across the Dnieper in the South coming from Crimea, with a column advancing NW. To the N, a cluster of breakouts on the E bank are beginning to fan out and another is joining with the enclave to the E. Other columns are pushing in from the N and E, and the siege of Kharkov and Kiev are also underway. Air strikes cluster on Kiev but are spread across the whole country.

U/D, March 3: The already taken zones are being consolidated and extended and columns are surging out. Most notably, from Crimea to the West, and the thrust to Kiev is being broadened.

U/D Mar 4: VDH analyses, pivoting on the Javelin anti-tank missile:

U/D March 5, map is revised on Mar 3rd:

Notice here fresh probes from White Russia, a thrust to the W along a major road net towards Poland, a swing back towards Kiev for a thrust that was apparently aiming to pinch off a chunk of Northern Ukraine continued columns from the NE and the continuation of the western breakout from Crimea. Kiev and Kharkov seem to be holding,

U/D2 Mar 5, a Daily Mail Map:

This Daily Mail map is more outline and differs in details but tells the same basic story.

U/D May 8, a screen shot from Russian TV with a marked up encirclement in the E:

Oh yes, apparently there is an enemies list:

  • All EU member States,
  • The USA
  • Australia
  • Albania
  • Andorra
  • Czech Republic
  • Great Britain (including Jersey, Anguilla, British Virgin Islands and Gibraltar)
  • Iceland
  • Canada
  • Liechtenstein
  • Micronesia
  • Monaco
  • New Zealand
  • Norway
  • Republic of Korea
  • San Marino
  • North Macedonia
  • Singapore
  • Taiwan
  • Ukraine
  • Montenegro
  • Switzerland
  • Japan

They left off a raft of UK OT’s there, including Cayman, Montserrat, Turks and Caicos Islands, Bermuda, Isle of Man, Falklands, Pitcairn, St Helena, South Georgia etc. I guess they list where their offshore accounts are and got frozen?

U/D March 9, Putin in Southern Africa as a trainer for guerilla leaders, 1973:

This is my comment on an iHarare piece brought to my attention by people inclined to cheer on anything that is suggested as aiding liberation from Western Imperialism. An objection was made in the combox, that Putin’s age would be 20-ish and his official life story puts him in law school at relevant times. I noted that he was KGB and we can expect contradictory narratives, where the window is that in which military service is likely. The association with two African Presidents of the left is noteworthy. I suggest, assume it is not in fact Putin, that would only lead to, Russians were engaged in geostrategic pushes in guise of liberation movements, some of which have proved disastrous for ordinary people in certain African countries. The geostrategic point remains.

U/D: Wiki map, March 6, showing armoured thrusts far beyond the zones identified in a Russian proposal for ceasefire terms. Notice, these are by and large conservative relative to what has been shown on Russian TV, scroll up:

U/D, Mar 15 – 20: Russian forces consolidate while keeping Kiev under pressure:

The consolidation ratchets up pressure on Ukraine, the attacks on the capital can lead to decision, negotiations seem stalled over Russia’s demand for neutrality, which has already been seen as invitation to invasion. Sanctions have been put in place but are seldom decisive.

Comments
I'm 100 % against any type of war (in the open or hidden) People who did this to US citizens are the same that did that to Ukrainian citizens. It's called "science". Question: What would you have done if you were Zelensky? Poor comedian has been played by US otherwise wouldn't have done what he did. He thought he will be helped by NATO after he was fooled by US to poke the bear ? You are not a hero arming convicted felons ,arming granma and Miss Ukraine , lying about the bravery and false death of soldiers from The snakes Island,etc. . He was the cause of millions of people leaving the country because he overplayed his hand . Now he understood that he got played and that he was just a pawn. I bet US didn't expect this reaction from Putin , I guess Zelensky didn't expect to be lied and then abandoned . How is this clown a hero if Ukraine is BROKEN ?Lieutenant Commander Data
March 8, 2022
March
03
Mar
8
08
2022
12:49 PM
12
12
49
PM
PDT
LCD, my problem is the history of appeasement and limited wrist slapping in the face of naked aggression has a very bad tendency to slide down a slippery slope heading off a cliff. If the Russians don't back down now, where does that lead? With the sort of obvious oligarchy, how could Russia back down? I do not like where this points. KFkairosfocus
March 8, 2022
March
03
Mar
8
08
2022
09:45 AM
9
09
45
AM
PDT
You Can't Cuck The Tuck: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1PC7DzTRS7ALieutenant Commander Data
March 8, 2022
March
03
Mar
8
08
2022
08:24 AM
8
08
24
AM
PDT
U/D, a snapshot from Russian TV, claiming control of large areas and a major encirclement in the East. Then, there is the enemies list.kairosfocus
March 8, 2022
March
03
Mar
8
08
2022
12:15 AM
12
12
15
AM
PDT
LCD, we don't know what Mr Putin or the apparent reporters think, just what they say and wish to project as narrative. They have forfeited presumption of truthfulness. This campaign is manifestly aggressive war targetting people who on the whole do not wish to be returned to what, historically, is the prison of nations. Others in the near neighbourhood are taking due note. KF PS, I am making my own geostrategic judgements, independent in the main from the media, who on the whole lack background.kairosfocus
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
08:24 PM
8
08
24
PM
PDT
I don't know if cnn aired this interview ,let's hear what Putin himself have to say about whole context AS HE SEE IT . At least everybody can judge directly if he make sense or not and then compare with legacy media . Putin explains the military situation and why Ukraine might lose its future. (push subtitle button)Lieutenant Commander Data
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
02:36 PM
2
02
36
PM
PDT
Not good. Russia: Tehran, Beijing, and Moscow Aligned To Win US Concessions on Nuclear Deal https://freebeacon.com/national-security/russia-tehran-beijing-and-moscow-aligned-to-win-us-concessions-on-nuclear-deal/ PS: Who will suffer? Not the elites. They have bunkers.Lieutenant Commander Data
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
01:48 PM
1
01
48
PM
PDT
Jerry, in a war situation, logistics has always been a major headache with plenty going wrong. The story of the Sacred Way in WW1 or the Red Ball Express and the breakdown of support for Patton's 3rd Army in WW2 will make the point. KFkairosfocus
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
11:56 AM
11
11
56
AM
PDT
A 20 minute video of failed Russian logistics. Doesn’t mean they will lose in Ukraine but their military is currently extremely hampered by logistics and geography. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4wRdoWpw0w&t=1167sjerry
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
10:28 AM
10
10
28
AM
PDT
Was the US funding illegal bio-weapon labs in Ukraine near the Russian border? Looks like it might prove out to be more than just a rumor. https://twitter.com/ASBMilitary/status/1500499470076854272William J Murray
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
07:07 AM
7
07
07
AM
PDT
Kairosfocus In my interaction with Russians in recent years, I would conclude that they tend to believe the narrative that Ukraine is a neo-Nazi state manipulated by NATO in a geostrategic plot
Warning: Graphic content https://t.co/FKBGgQH01y Fake or true? https://twitter.com/mission_russian/status/1499704131015036930Lieutenant Commander Data
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
03:48 AM
3
03
48
AM
PDT
Anthropic, a very different situation. Scroll up and see from the maps what armoured columns, helicopters, missiles etc are doing in historic tank country, sometimes in the same places from 1941 - 44. Recall, in 1975 the final thrust was armoured in Vietnam and a similar campaign conquered Cambodia too. The Russians are winning operationally, at casualty rates at least an order of magnitude below what happened in the 1940's. They have crossed the Dnieper, the major Riverine barrier. Kiev and Kharkov are effectively under siege and they have taken power plants more or less at will. Yes, the Ukrainians can extract a cost but historically Russia has not been anywhere nearly as casualty sensitive as the US and the Russian press is a lot less free than the US was in the 1960's or even recently -- Afghanistan -- so a home-front defeat by loss of will is unlikely. In my interaction with Russians in recent years, I would conclude that they tend to believe the narrative that Ukraine is a neo-Nazi state manipulated by NATO in a geostrategic plot against the Rodina, and they are very aware that The Great Patriotic War was largely decided in or near to the Ukraine. See Gen Flynn above on what might be a way forward. KFkairosfocus
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
03:22 AM
3
03
22
AM
PDT
"Sev, the problem is, the parlous state of the militaries that would have to back up any words of challenge. The cupboard is bare. Which, Putin manifestly judged before striking. KF" Putin misjudged the moment. The Ukrainian people will supply the blood & determination if we supply the weapons. Just like Russia & China did for North Vietnam.anthropic
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
12:57 AM
12
12
57
AM
PDT
Ram @185 said:
I’m getting reports from fellow ham radio operators, and from a Ukrainian woman that I am associated with, who has family and friends in Ukraine. No media filters involved.
I'm not sure how that has anything to do with what you quoted in that comment. I wasn't talking about you.William J Murray
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
12:48 AM
12
12
48
AM
PDT
Oil: https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2022/03/06/u-s-crude-soars-above-130-a-barrel/
The price of oil surged on Sunday evening, putting pressure on gasoline prices and inflation. West Texas Intermediate crude futures, the U.S. benchmark rose as high as $130.50 a barrel before retreating to $123.09. WTI’s highest price since 1983 was $143.67 in 2008. Adjusted for inflation that would be $186.73. Brent crude futures, the global benchmark, traded as high as $139.13 on Sunday evening. By 8:45 P.M. EST, Brent was down to $126.30. Oil prices have risen on fears of a full embargo against Russian oil, which accounted for about 10 percent of the global supply before the invasion of Ukraine. As well, many in the market are refusing to bid, ship, or unload Russian oil, pushing up demand for other sources. The Russian benchmark, known as Urals, has traded at a steep discount to Brent over the past week. The national average price for a gallon of gas has skyrocketed to $4.00 – the highest national average in nearly 14 years.
Notice how much inflation there has been. Recall, Russia is an oil state. KFkairosfocus
March 7, 2022
March
03
Mar
7
07
2022
12:05 AM
12
12
05
AM
PDT
Sev, the problem is, the parlous state of the militaries that would have to back up any words of challenge. The cupboard is bare. Which, Putin manifestly judged before striking. KFkairosfocus
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
11:59 PM
11
11
59
PM
PDT
WJM: There is no evil being perpetrated right before my very eyes. There is some imagery and some talking heads providing a narrative about what that imagery is of and means on some devices I use mostly for entertainment. I'm getting reports from fellow ham radio operators, and from a Ukrainian woman that I am associated with, who has family and friends in Ukraine. No media filters involved. --Ramram
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
11:32 PM
11
11
32
PM
PDT
Under Joe Biden: -2 US Embassies were evacuated -Gas prices are over $4/gallon -Inflation is at a 40 year high -Russia has invaded Ukraine -Afghanistan is controlled by the Taliban -Grocery prices are up 20% - Billions of state of the art military equipment left in Afghanistan -13 Marines killed - A drone strike that killed an Afghan family - Oil prices doubled And we are only a year and half in. Vividvividbleau
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
06:05 PM
6
06
05
PM
PDT
Whatever claim Putin may try to make on Ukraine, either based on reality or his own fiction, it will never outweigh the people’s right to a free and fair election for a government that represents them.
C'mon man! :lol: That explains why Lindsey Graham snaped . Hope he will never be elected again. Lindsey Graham in UkraineLieutenant Commander Data
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
06:01 PM
6
06
01
PM
PDT
Kairosfocus/177
F/N: With all due respect to those who do not wish to hear from the site, Gen Flynn has put up a proposal on the Ukraine
I would say that Flynn's case has merit but it depends crucially on the assumption that Putin is being honest about his only real concern being to prevent Ukraine joining NATO because he feels threatened by an Alliance state on his borders. If, on the other hand, his real motive is to try and rebuild something like the old Soviet Union, which would mean bringing former Soviet satellite states - meaning not just Ukraine but Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Poland, Hungary and even Finland - back under Russian hegemony then all bets are off. In this case there is only one way to stop him and it would be better done now than later.Seversky
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
05:55 PM
5
05
55
PM
PDT
Even if Western leadership finds the backbone to stand up to Putin, this situation is going to get worse before it gets better. if they don't take more forceful action to stop him - and I see little prospect of this happening with current leadership in the West - it's going to get a lot worse.Seversky
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
05:35 PM
5
05
35
PM
PDT
I think the White House just broke the petrodollar, not good for the US. If so If you think things are bad now on the inflation front you have not seen anything yet. Oil currently at 125 a barrel Vividvividbleau
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
04:55 PM
4
04
55
PM
PDT
F/N: It seems several Russian senior officers have been killed; a sign they are leading from the front. KFkairosfocus
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
02:13 PM
2
02
13
PM
PDT
Another article by Peter Hitchens on Ukraine
One glorious day in Sevastopol 12 years ago, I saw what was coming. That's why I won't join this carnival of hypocrisy
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-10581335/PETER-HITCHENS-saw-coming-Thats-wont-join-carnival-hypocrisy.htmljerry
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
01:10 PM
1
01
10
PM
PDT
F/N: With all due respect to those who do not wish to hear from the site, Gen Flynn has put up a proposal on the Ukraine https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2022/03/exclusive-gen-flynn-can-end-ukraine-crisis-today/
. . . There is an option that would give Putin an out. This option needs to be thoroughly analyzed and discussed. It gets Putin what he wants, affords Ukraine a unique and long-term security opportunity, allows Europe and the world to take a deep breath, and can stop this madness along with the horrible killing taking place on both sides (and this may only be the beginning). I believe the key to unlocking this crisis is the Budapest Agreement. As smart readers will remember, when the Soviet Union broke up after decades of the now-distant Cold War, Ukraine had more nuclear weapons than China and was the third-biggest nuclear power in the world. Among other critical issues, the Budapest Agreement stipulated that Ukraine would give up its nuclear weapons if both Russia and the U.S. agreed not to invade it. That is the basic agreement. Putin is in gross violation of this agreement, which affords the U.S. (and select European nations) the opportunity to enforce it. But this is only a starting point to a broader conversation about a peaceful solution. The real conversation goes like this. Part One: Russia wants a neutral Ukraine. The Budapest Agreement can be considered an agreement of neutrality. Obviously, if Russia adheres to the agreement, then Ukraine doesn’t need to join NATO. And NATO can agree that having Ukraine join would be a violation of the Budapest accord. This is something that I believe Putin would seriously consider (and possibly accept), and it meets half of his demands. This gives him a way out without killing more people. Part Two: Putin wants Ukraine to renounce any claim to Crimea. Ukraine should agree, with a major caveat. Putin argues that Crimea was unlawfully given to Ukraine in the 1950s and, true or not, he wants it back. Well, Ukraine will never get Crimea back under any conditions without a major war. Most don’t realize it, but Putin is popular in Crimea and there is a strong attachment to Russia in the region, so it is a loss to Ukraine, but not a substantial loss. (That is the reality of global geopolitics.) The major caveat should be that Ukraine has made a lot of improvements in Crimea since the ’50s. A large price should be put on that. Russia is not just taking Crimea; it is paying for all the care that Ukraine has given Crimea since the ’50s. It should be a significant and long-term repayment. Part Three: Finally, Putin must emphasize that the targeting of civilians was against his orders and that he will help to rebuild some of Ukraine. He can claim that senior generals or other Russian defense officials failed to follow his orders and publicly fire them. (Maybe those fired will be allowed to come to the U.S. and work at a Washington, D.C., think tank). However the provision may be described, it gives Putin the chance to call this insane war off. In the end, America has always stood for self-determination and the right to choose one’s government. Whatever claim Putin may try to make on Ukraine, either based on reality or his own fiction, it will never outweigh the people’s right to a free and fair election for a government that represents them. As another famous president said about a voting bloc in our country, what do you have to lose? I do think this would be agreeable to Putin if the alternative is brutal sanctions and a reputation as a pariah. What I don’t know is whether Ukraine would be agreeable. I do believe that if Ukraine can forgo NATO, it should be given immediate consideration for European Union membership. Obviously, Crimea would be a bigger pill to swallow, but Ukraine isn’t getting it back anyway. Bite the bullet for the good of humanity and the reality that you stand to lose your entire nation or worse if the situation continues. Push for a large payment from Russia and it will likely give it. On this latter note, which I’m certain will get the most attention, Russia will lose the money in any case, either to economy-crushing sanctions or in paying back Ukraine. Better the money goes to Ukraine than just disappears due to sanctions. Russia doesn’t lose too much, and Ukraine gains a lot.
This is a case where a reasonable compromise is better than a war prone to escalation. KFkairosfocus
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
12:05 PM
12
12
05
PM
PDT
"With Russian forces besieging Mariupol, in which 120,000+ ethnic Greeks live, SKAI (Greece )news spoke with a Mr Kiouranas who lives in the city and exposed that Ukrainian “fascists” are killing people for trying to leave the city. " https://greekcitytimes.com/2022/03/01/greek-in-mariupol-fascist-ukrainian/ Ukrainians (Azov Batalion ) need people as human shields against russian army. A french journalist about Ukrainians bombing their own civilians: https://twitter.com/MaxSteele45/status/1500332784841371650 PS: A message for all the woke : https://twitter.com/LtCdrStacy/status/1500513990031466498Lieutenant Commander Data
March 6, 2022
March
03
Mar
6
06
2022
10:04 AM
10
10
04
AM
PDT
Another take by Mark Steyn. This is more apocalyptic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QufGDOZzSoojerry
March 5, 2022
March
03
Mar
5
05
2022
11:35 AM
11
11
35
AM
PDT
Wikileaks is gold: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/1499837835758604290Lieutenant Commander Data
March 5, 2022
March
03
Mar
5
05
2022
11:27 AM
11
11
27
AM
PDT
WJM Ok, yes I didn't read that correctly. Thanks.Silver Asiatic
March 5, 2022
March
03
Mar
5
05
2022
10:33 AM
10
10
33
AM
PDT
SA, I think his reference was made clear by his use of the term "information potential."William J Murray
March 5, 2022
March
03
Mar
5
05
2022
09:43 AM
9
09
43
AM
PDT
1 2 3 4 5 9

Leave a Reply