Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

BREAKING/DEVELOPING: Russia invades Ukraine

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email
Wikipedia initial map of the invasion, especially note a reported incursion from western Belarus and the main weight of reported bombings and incursions in the eastern trans-Dnieper region, the DonBass

BBC announces:

Russian forces have launched a military assault on neighbouring Ukraine, crossing its borders and bombing military targets near big cities.

A residential building in Chuguev was destroyed after it was shelled.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has warned that Moscow’s response will be “instant” if anyone tries to take on Russia.

Ukraine has urged the UN “to do everything possible” to stop what it says is a full-scale war.

We could title this, the geostrategic price of weakness, starting with the USA. Recall here, my 2016 framework:

Of course as this seems overnight the fog of war is very much in effect and we need to bear in mind that we are unlikely to have a full or reliable picture. DEVELOPING, UPDATES TO FOLLOW

U/D Feb 25, a map of the course of the invasion:

Wikipedia’s updated but provisional map c Feb 24, showing reported lines of thrust. Note, provisional

U/D Feb 27: Wiki Map Feb 26

Wiki map c Feb 26, showing lodgement areas, thrusts and move to decapitate by taking Kiev

U/D Feb 28, let’s insert the Feb 28 Wiki map to compare:

U/D Feb 27: HT Daily Mail, a map of detail fighting near Kiev:

HT, Daily Mail, on fighting near Kiev. Seizing an airport as an air head is a known standard modern tactic for the side with air superiority. Compare Bagram in Afghanistan and its abandonment just before the US fleeing from Afghanistan

U/D, Feb 27: Geostrategic considerations:

U/D Feb 28, Putin puts nuke forces to high alert, issues implied threats, even as he agrees to talks — vid:

U/D Mar 1: Overnight on the updated operational situation map at Wikipedia:

Update overnight Feb 28/Mar 1. We see a bridgehead across the Dnieper in the South coming from Crimea, with a column advancing NW. To the N, a cluster of breakouts on the E bank are beginning to fan out and another is joining with the enclave to the E. Other columns are pushing in from the N and E, and the siege of Kharkov and Kiev are also underway. Air strikes cluster on Kiev but are spread across the whole country.

U/D, March 3: The already taken zones are being consolidated and extended and columns are surging out. Most notably, from Crimea to the West, and the thrust to Kiev is being broadened.

U/D Mar 4: VDH analyses, pivoting on the Javelin anti-tank missile:

U/D March 5, map is revised on Mar 3rd:

Notice here fresh probes from White Russia, a thrust to the W along a major road net towards Poland, a swing back towards Kiev for a thrust that was apparently aiming to pinch off a chunk of Northern Ukraine continued columns from the NE and the continuation of the western breakout from Crimea. Kiev and Kharkov seem to be holding,

U/D2 Mar 5, a Daily Mail Map:

This Daily Mail map is more outline and differs in details but tells the same basic story.

U/D May 8, a screen shot from Russian TV with a marked up encirclement in the E:

Oh yes, apparently there is an enemies list:

  • All EU member States,
  • The USA
  • Australia
  • Albania
  • Andorra
  • Czech Republic
  • Great Britain (including Jersey, Anguilla, British Virgin Islands and Gibraltar)
  • Iceland
  • Canada
  • Liechtenstein
  • Micronesia
  • Monaco
  • New Zealand
  • Norway
  • Republic of Korea
  • San Marino
  • North Macedonia
  • Singapore
  • Taiwan
  • Ukraine
  • Montenegro
  • Switzerland
  • Japan

They left off a raft of UK OT’s there, including Cayman, Montserrat, Turks and Caicos Islands, Bermuda, Isle of Man, Falklands, Pitcairn, St Helena, South Georgia etc. I guess they list where their offshore accounts are and got frozen?

U/D March 9, Putin in Southern Africa as a trainer for guerilla leaders, 1973:

This is my comment on an iHarare piece brought to my attention by people inclined to cheer on anything that is suggested as aiding liberation from Western Imperialism. An objection was made in the combox, that Putin’s age would be 20-ish and his official life story puts him in law school at relevant times. I noted that he was KGB and we can expect contradictory narratives, where the window is that in which military service is likely. The association with two African Presidents of the left is noteworthy. I suggest, assume it is not in fact Putin, that would only lead to, Russians were engaged in geostrategic pushes in guise of liberation movements, some of which have proved disastrous for ordinary people in certain African countries. The geostrategic point remains.

U/D: Wiki map, March 6, showing armoured thrusts far beyond the zones identified in a Russian proposal for ceasefire terms. Notice, these are by and large conservative relative to what has been shown on Russian TV, scroll up:

U/D, Mar 15 – 20: Russian forces consolidate while keeping Kiev under pressure:

The consolidation ratchets up pressure on Ukraine, the attacks on the capital can lead to decision, negotiations seem stalled over Russia’s demand for neutrality, which has already been seen as invitation to invasion. Sanctions have been put in place but are seldom decisive.

Comments
Who cares what Putin's excuse is? It's all a pretext for his expansionism, his apparent desire to rebuild something like the old Soviet Union. And it's looking increasingly like Biden is a modern-day Neville Chamberlain - well-meaning, perhaps, but seriously and dangerously misguided.Seversky
February 25, 2022
February
02
Feb
25
25
2022
03:29 AM
3
03
29
AM
PDT
It seems they expect Kiev to fall within four days. Intent is to install a puppet government. Excuse is, the president -- a Jew -- is a Nazi.kairosfocus
February 25, 2022
February
02
Feb
25
25
2022
02:43 AM
2
02
43
AM
PDT
The only thing that would have stopped the invasion of Russian forces into an independent Ukraine, which does have distinct borders and government, was the same thing that would have continued to bring stability to Afghanistan. A small contingent of American forces in Ukraine would have stopped the invasion from ever happening. Putin is smart and calculating. To kill and claw his way up the KGB ladder to the point of running East Germany, requires someone very smart and able to think several steps ahead, while being absolutely ruthless. The Russian military, even going back to the old empire under czars, has a press until steel mindset. They take on weaker forces, but back off when it comes to serious military power. That was the reason Napoleon was never fought in the open field. Despite what some may think of Trump, the invasions of Ukraine did not happen under his watch. First was Obama and now under Biden. Trump came off from a position of strength from Putin's perspective.BobRyan
February 25, 2022
February
02
Feb
25
25
2022
01:18 AM
1
01
18
AM
PDT
The truth about the Ukraine https://www.revolver.news/2022/02/obama-was-right-no-gae-war-with-russia/ Vividvividbleau
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
10:56 PM
10
10
56
PM
PDT
Unfortunately it looks like Putin is not a 4D chess player. He ended up doing the bidding of the WEF, even if reluctantly. Had he been that concerned about NATO, he should have prevented Maidan back in 2013, yet he didn't, thus giving the WEF this obvious card to play at any time they wanted to. Of course, there is always the darker possibility that he is a straight WEF collaborator, helping the WEF to establish their new "multi-polar world" model with this little war.Eugene
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
10:01 PM
10
10
01
PM
PDT
Sev and Sc: Kindly refrain from school yard level personalities. We are dealing with consequences of geostrategic failure [coming hard on the heels of similar failure in Afghanistan and likely pointing to trouble with Taiwan and Iran etc], with direct parallels to the 1930's that beg to be drawn out. Churchill was a deeply flawed and widely despised man at that time, but unfortunately he was right. You may find his 1938 work, While England Slept, to be useful though unhappy reading https://archive.org/details/whileenglandslep00chur We are dealing with Mackinder's Pivot area of the Heartland, with implications for the credibility of NATO and UN (similar to the League of Nations in the '30's), pointing to awful possibilities. The time for silly posturing is over. Let us never forget that Churchill came to power May 10 1940, the same day ten Stuka and Messerchmitt backed Panzer Divisions rolled westward, seven in the now notorious breakthrough in the Ardennes. KF PS, Yes, Churchill's six volume history of WW2 was begun even before the full outbreak of war.kairosfocus
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
09:11 PM
9
09
11
PM
PDT
And to be a role model for truthfulness, tolerance, fidelity and racial/cultural equality.Scamp
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:51 PM
6
06
51
PM
PDT
Remember, it is sacrilege to criticize the Great Orange Cheeto. It has been anointed by God to lead us out of ungreatness back to greatness..Seversky
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:35 PM
6
06
35
PM
PDT
Scamp Sadly, I think the orange Cheeto
Please don't call your owm mommy the orange Cheeto even she is a Cheeto and didn't give you the proper education. ;)Sandy
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
10:34 AM
10
10
34
AM
PDT
How the Greens Brought War to Ukraine It’s hard to keep from laughing at the leaders who created this mess to curry favor, votes and money from the Greens. Take, for example, German chancellor Olaf Scholz whose contribution to the fight was halting the certification of the Nord Stream 2 Baltic gas pipeline. I’d put my money on the halt being temporary. Germany already gets half its gas from Russia. Germans are facing record energy prices and the government is tapping its treasury to ease consumer pressure. Dmitry Medvedev, former Russian president could not restrain himself. “Welcome to the new world where Europeans will soon have to pay 2,000 euros per thousand cubic meters.” Were I a friend of Chancellor Scholz I’d whisper in his ear a suggestion from Andrew A Michta, that the best way to show Putin you mean business is not to make an unlikely threat but rather to halt the plan to shut down its three remaining nuclear reactors in Emsland, Isar and Neckarwestheim that the post-Merkel Germans have foolishly scheduled to shut down this year. Much of the same advice should be given to the Biden administration—undo the restrictions you are forcing on conventional energy production if you want to show you are serious. Of course, no one would consider this administration serious.
https://the-pipeline.org/how-the-greens-brought-war-to-ukraine/jerry
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
08:01 AM
8
08
01
AM
PDT
Getting political - If you wonder why Trump at age 75 has high support
little over a year ago when Trump was President ... - no inflation. - no southern border invasion. - gas was $1.75 per gallon. - no war in Ukraine.
But he did do mean tweets. If you want to know why there is war in Ukraine, here are a couple of the reasons 1) blatant lying by the press And 2) increased energy price caused by Biden and Democrats https://twitter.com/TheRightWingM/status/1496336404300943360 From BabylonBee
Biden Approval Rating In Ukraine Drops To 0%
https://babylonbee.com/news/biden-approval-rating-in-ukraine-drops-to-0 Remember https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6zFXc_CNR8 They were also investigating his son’s relationship with Ukrainejerry
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
07:35 AM
7
07
35
AM
PDT
[Ukraine's] relatively free press ... The Ukrainian president hasn't hesitated to shut down media sources in a unilateral manner - in a way we wouldn't do in the US, for example. So, it's not that much of a free press. And it's not a democratic process.
KYIV, Jan 6 (Reuters) - Ukraine's pro-Western opposition accused President Volodymyr Zelenskiy of autocratic behaviour on Thursday after a court froze the assets of Zelenskiy's predecessor Petro Poroshenko and two television channels that once belonged to him. The asset seizures were part of a formal investigation into whether Poroshenko committed high treason by financing Russian-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine while in office in 2014-2015. He has denied the allegations. Poroshenko's European Solidarity party called the ruling by Kyiv's Pechersk court "illegal, unjust" and designed to silence opposition to Zelenskiy's rule. https://www.reuters.com/markets/rates-bonds/ukrainian-court-freezes-property-ex-president-poroshenko-2022-01-06/
Silver Asiatic
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
07:16 AM
7
07
16
AM
PDT
Greta Rules
I’m so glad that the west gave up on energy independence because Greta Thunberg yelled at us. That’s really looking like a smart move today.
https://mobile.twitter.com/MattWalshBlog/status/1496822822999494657 I wonder what Greta thinks of this. https://mobile.twitter.com/Jeffincats/status/1496828651991674889 The Canadian government is forever grateful because It’s not a slow news day Unfortunately for millions the lies about climate change and the virus are causing incredible harm. When will we learn that truth not lies will be the answer to a better life.jerry
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
07:02 AM
7
07
02
AM
PDT
AP, Yahoo News https://www.yahoo.com/news/russia-attacks-ukraine-defiant-putin-055130690.html >>The consequences of the conflict and resulting sanctions on Russia started reverberating throughout the world. World stock markets plunged and oil prices surged by nearly $8 per barrel. Market benchmarks tumbled in Europe and Asia and U.S. stocks pointed toward a sharply lower open. Brent crude oil jumped to over $100 per barrel Thursday on unease about possible disruption of Russian supplies. The ruble sank. Anticipating international condemnation and countermeasures, Putin issued a stark warning to other countries not to meddle. In a reminder of Russia’s nuclear power, Putin warned that “no one should have any doubts that a direct attack on our country will lead to the destruction and horrible consequences for any potential aggressor.” Among Putin’s pledges was to “denazify” Ukraine. World War II looms large in Russia, after the Soviet Union suffered more deaths than any country while fighting Adolf Hitler’s forces. Kremlin propaganda sometimes paints Ukrainian nationalists as neo-Nazis seeking revenge — a charge historians call disinformation. Ukraine is now led by a Jewish president who lost relatives in the Holocaust. Putin’s announcement came just hours after the Ukrainian president rejected Moscow’s claims that his country poses a threat to Russia and made a passionate, last-minute plea for peace. “The people of Ukraine and the government of Ukraine want peace,” Zelenskyy said in an emotional overnight address, speaking in Russian in a direct appeal to Russian citizens.>>kairosfocus
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:44 AM
6
06
44
AM
PDT
Sev, genius and goodness are not the same. Hitler was a genius to our sad cost. There is a price for playing dirty domestic politics for the regime in power in the US and elsewhere. KFkairosfocus
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:39 AM
6
06
39
AM
PDT
Seversky: The narcissistic 45th president on the other hand thinks Putin is a genius and so, apparently do his toadies which makes them a total loss.
Sadly, I think the orange Cheeto is correct. Putin has accurately read the extent to which the west will respond and accurately estimates that the response will be impotent.Scamp
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:39 AM
6
06
39
AM
PDT
The Ukraine has a government, judiciary, police and armed forces, a relatively free press and holds relatively free elections. It is a nation by any reasonable definition and Russia is in gross violation of the UN Charter by invading its territory. What concerns me is that Putin has calculated correctly on weak and ineffectual leadership in the West. I am wiling to give Biden and Harris a chance to show they have the backbone to stand up to Putin but they don't have much time. Sanctions and prayers aren't going to cut it and we have the lesson of the Sudetenland of what happens when you try to appease dictators. The narcissistic 45th president on the other hand thinks Putin is a genius and so, apparently do his toadies which makes them a total loss. Boris Johnson is little more than a joke and so is Macron. The Germans try not to get involved in wars these days for obvious reasons so who does that leave?Seversky
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
06:15 AM
6
06
15
AM
PDT
The plain fact is that Ukraine has ALWAYS been part of Russia. These are not separate nations
Not true. The Ukraine has never been a single nationality as the people who make up the Ukraine have lived under several different kingdoms. If one can pinpoint just who Ukrainians are they are a genius. At various times, they were under Polish, Lithuanian, Hungarian, German or Russian control. And sometimes parts were independent. They were never a single nationality. My wife is half Ukrainian and her great grandparents spoke 4-5 languages depending on who was controlling where they lived in Lviv. Funny thing of the day: when doing a search for Ukraine, the first thing that appears is an ad for vacation rentals in Ukraine - perfect for family and budgets of all sizes. An example - Lviv - Besides its Ukrainian name, and its ancient Ruthenian name of Lwihorod Lvihorod, the city is also known by several other names in different languages: Polish Lwów; German Lemberg; Yiddish ??????? Lemberg or ???????? Lèmberik; Russian ????? L'vov; Hungarian Ilyvó; Serbo-Croatian Lavov; Romanian Liov; Latin Leopolis (meaning "lion city", from Ancient Greek ???? ????? Lé?n Pólis); Crimean Tatar ?lbav; Middle Armenian ???? Ilov; Armeno-Kipchak ???? Ilôv; and a number of other namesjerry
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
05:02 AM
5
05
02
AM
PDT
P, not always, try the time of the Polish-Lithuanian power as a great power, just for one reference. And, the hovering ghost is that of Germany c 1936 - 8, with the capture of Austria and of Czechoslovakia. KFkairosfocus
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
04:44 AM
4
04
44
AM
PDT
The plain fact is that Ukraine has ALWAYS been part of Russia. These are not separate nations.polistra
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
03:54 AM
3
03
54
AM
PDT
BREAKING/DEVELOPING: Russia invades Ukrainekairosfocus
February 24, 2022
February
02
Feb
24
24
2022
03:32 AM
3
03
32
AM
PDT
1 7 8 9

Leave a Reply