Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

BREAKING: President Trump, Mrs Trump & Ms Hicks are Positive for CV-19

Categories
News Highlights
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Tweets:

Tonight, @ FLOTUS and I tested positive for COVID-19. We will begin our quarantine and recovery process immediately. We will get through this TOGETHER!
— Donald J. Trump (@ realDonaldTrump) October 2, 2020

Hope Hicks, who has been working so hard without even taking a small break, has just tested positive for Covid 19. Terrible! The First Lady and I are waiting for our test results. In the meantime, we will begin our quarantine process!
— Donald J. Trump (@ realDonaldTrump) October 2, 2020

When you thought an extraordinarily chaotic year could not pull out another twist. Well, here it is. END

PS: As broad context

PPS: For reference on HCQ

Also:

PPPS: A sampler from a former CEO, Twitter (cf discussion at Forbes [also here]) commented on by Michelle Malkin, a few days ago:

See, now, that this is NOT a normal silly season cycle?

PPPPS: A summary on the U/L trajectory of CV19:

Comments
For those interested in the effectiveness of masks, here is a video that provides an extensive look at research data for all types of masks. It is about an hour long and very thorough. https://bit.ly/3ixFt1T Recommend that if you look at it, do so on a computer. I tried an iPad and had difficultly controlling it but had no problem on a computer.jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
03:01 PM
3
03
01
PM
PST
seversky:
Democrats have been more rigorous in adopting precautionary measures?
By hiding and not doing their jobs. :razz:ET
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
02:54 PM
2
02
54
PM
PST
Jerry/57
For those interested. A 126 studies on HCQ. https://c19study.com/
COVIDAnalysis network A network of websites that have cherry-picked and misrepresented research to promote hydroxychloroquine as a proven treatment for COVID-19, despite clinical trials finding that it is not effective.
The COVIDAnalysis network, which includes C19Study.com, C19HCQ.com, and HCQTrial.com, does not disclose its ownership on the sites and would not disclose it to NewsGuard, nor could NewsGuard independently determine who owns the network. Thus, there is no way to know if the sites — which are not financed by advertising or subscriptions — are financed by those with a financial or political interest related to the promotion of hydroxychloroquine. […] The COVIDAnalysis network’s list of studies has repeatedly misrepresented the conclusions of clinical trials that found that hydroxychloroquine provided no benefit for COVID-19 patients. For example, the websites described a clinical trial at the University of Minnesota as being “positive” for the use of hydroxychloroquine for treating COVID-19, when the actual study reached a negative conclusion. The trial, involving 821 patients, found that hydroxychloroquine did not perform better than a placebo in preventing people from developing COVID19 after they were likely to have been exposed to someone who had been infected. The study was published in June 2020 in the New England Journal of Medicine. […] Boulware also said that the websites’ analysis included a fabricated quote about his own comments on the study. C19Study.com and C19HCQ.com cited a since- deleted tweet from a Twitter account named “T Lewis MD,” which said, “I personally spoke to Boulware about this study. He points out its many flaws. He also points out that day 1-3 use had statistical significance and he’s gearing his other studies accordingly. He intends to investigate this significance further.” Boulware told NewsGuard that he never spoke to anyone associated with that Twitter account, calling the comment attributed to him and cited by the COVIDAnalysis network “100% False – coming from someone who chose to make up a false statement on Twitter.” After NewsGuard asked the sites’ representative about Boulware’s comments, the websites removed the Twitter comment from the article. “We have removed a comment from Dr. Lewis because it was deleted and Dr. Boulware indicates it was incorrect,” an update note on C19Study.com and C19HCQ.com stated. The sites’ study list includes a clinical trial involving 400 patients, also conducted by researchers at the University of Minnesota and published in the Annals of Internal Medicine in July 2020, that concluded that hydroxychloroquine did not decrease the severity of COVID-19 symptoms over 14 days any better than a placebo in patients who were not hospitalized. The COVIDAnalysis network, however, listed the study’s results as “inconclusive” instead of “negative.” When NewsGuard asked what justified this interpretation of the study, the websites’ anonymous representative claimed the trial was ended prematurely. “The trial was supposed to have 1,242 patients. i.e., they chose to stop it early although they knew at the time they would likely be reporting a statistically significant positive reduction if they continued,” the representative said. “Since they answer your questions, can you ask them why they stopped the trial early in the context of this information?” Asked about this, Boulware told NewsGuard that the websites’ statement that there “could be an unknown number of undetected fake surveys” in the trial was groundless. “Being that the majority of participants were healthcare workers, we don’t have any reason to believe that the participants who completed surveys (many of whom we had email or phone conversations with), are at all ‘fake,’” he said. “We did screen out and exclude a few persons from participating in the trial who did not have valid emails, phone numbers, addresses, or provided inconsistent information during the screening procedures.”
Seversky
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
02:51 PM
2
02
51
PM
PST
Does anyone else find it odd that no prominent Democrats have had the virus but the list of Republicans goes on and on?
There's no accounting for taste? Democrats have been more rigorous in adopting precautionary measures? Cocktails of HCL and Clorox, even if shaken not stirred, don't seem to work?Seversky
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
02:11 PM
2
02
11
PM
PST
Trump "disinfectant". He was talking about UV light. Not bleach some other liquid. Read the full context.mike1962
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
01:51 PM
1
01
51
PM
PST
Jerry, First, masks. I think felted and cloth meshes with enough fuzz will exert intermolecular, London forces and will trap significant numbers of viri and more to the point droplets. Think of how a cloth duster picks up dust. So, an increment with other things. As to logic and evidence, after years here I am led to conclude that we are rotten at these. We simply have not been soundly taught. A lot of what looks like reasoning is more following the dominant narrative party line. Appeal to blind following of alleged consensus authority. On another case, I see a lot of it with the chattering classes nattering away on climate issues they haven't got a clue on substantially. They also duly scorn whoever is the target of the two minute hate. Beyond this, too much of our statistics, mathematical modelling and computer simulation has been rooted in crucial logical and evidence errors at the beginning so they create a highly misleading aura of credibility. Taleb talks about Black Swans, and that's one issue. In short, first we are not sound so we are vulnerable to winds and waves of seemingly prestigious claims or teachings solemnly announced as consensus (up to no true saxon type errors) and yes that makes us also open to cunning and craftiness of willfully deceitful power-hungry manipulators and the outright greedy. Then, BECAUSE what is genuinely true cannot match a crooked yardstick, those enmeshed in webs of folly will reject the truth. Sad. Sandbars of Syrtis ahead, on line of drift in the storm. KFkairosfocus
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
01:17 PM
1
01
17
PM
PST
because masks are “required.”
Is the objective to have masks permanent? Some are saying that masks should have been used in past flu seasons because they would have reduced deaths with the intention of having them required anytime a virus appears such as every flu season. And definitely in schools.jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
01:12 PM
1
01
12
PM
PST
How effective are cloth masks stopping viruses? How effective is a chain link fence stopping mosquitos? Yes, I wear a mask when I go to the grocery store etc... not because I believe masks are effective but because masks are “required.”john_a_designer
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
10:52 AM
10
10
52
AM
PST
For those interested. A 126 studies on HCQ. https://c19study.com/
126 HCQ studies 76 peer reviewed Early treatment of COVID-19 with HCQ shows high efficacy Early down 64% PrEP down 49% All down 34% Late down 26% PEP down 24% PREP - pre exposure PEP - post exposure
One of the negative studies on HCQ gave lethal doses to hospitalized patients already very sick. This was the Oxford Recovery study. Overwhelming evidence HCQ has some positive effect. So HCQ is safe, effective and incredibly cheap. No drug company is going to make any money off it, zinc, azithromycin, vitamin D or C or ivermectin or many other possibilities. So the moral question is why withhold it from anyone? Downside, nothing bad happens. Upside a million + get to live longer. One life is tragic, a million lives are just statistical dots. The real downside is for the drug companies who see their expensive treatments flying away and those politically invested in wanting to see the current political order upended.jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
10:26 AM
10
10
26
AM
PST
Jerry: for Ferris wheel scene in the Third Man as Harry Lyme talks about the dead as dots as he makes money off of an ineffective vaccine. Is this what the anti HCQ people are defending? It appears so. It's a great scene, partially improvised apparently. And one of my favourite movies ever. The complete portrait of a shyster: clever, witty, opportunistic but cold blooded and self-centred to a fault. But the question is: which view agrees with the preponderance of the known science (acknowledging the fact that new data requires reevaluation of views)? I'm not talking about 'plausible' functionality, that's why new drugs have to go through a long process of establishing that they are effective as opposed to just looking good in theory. I'm talking about established, clinical evidence. I am talking about taking in all the data not just picking and choosing. If someone wants to declare the truth when they have not looked at and considered all the evidence then they've got something to sell. If you're right then you should be able to address everything even the stuff that is contrary to your view.JVL
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
09:41 AM
9
09
41
AM
PST
These dipsticks really screwed the pooch on this one. Weeks away from a critical election, and they can't mask up and keep their hands off each other. It's just incredibly irresponsible.daveS
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
09:27 AM
9
09
27
AM
PST
Kf, I have to disagree with you. Originally I thought it was all politics and related to Trump. It is obvious that's what is going on here at UD. The anti HCQ posters here are all based on politics. None are profiting from this in any way financially. But then as medical authorities chimed in and spread obvious misinformation, I started to wonder. Was there a different motive behind a lot of this besides politics? Then the Lancet debacle was brushed aside like it never happened. Just consider what it would do to the pharmaceutical industry if the need for most vaccines and many drugs disappeared and replaced with extremely inexpensive and maybe better alternatives. If something like HCQ and zinc could treat the biggest threat of the last 50 years what else could simple combinations of drugs/supplements also treat? I don't believe it is because we are weaker on logic or statistics. I do believe that evidence and logic will not overcome feeling or attitudes but people sure can use both when it suits them. So it is not because they cannot use them. A very informative site for C19 is https://rationalground.com and here are two articles on medical misinformation https://rationalground.com/mistake-or-manipulation/ Here's another one on herd immunity https://rationalground.com/educating-dr-fauci-on-herd-immunity-and-covid-19-completing-what-rand-paul-began/ ------------------ An aside. the link above for the Third Man scene with Orson Wells is https://bit.ly/3aMWiC4jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
08:32 AM
8
08
32
AM
PST
Jerry, I don't think greed is main driver. We should not underestimate the fallacy of telling truth or effectiveness by the clock, in a context where pandemics move fast by definition so the sweet spot is old approved drugs -- cut out basic short and long term safety demonstration issues --with multiple action, e.g. HCQ is ionophore and a weak base that readily enters cells. But there is no market for this and with exceptions research is looking for the new not the old. Then factor in gold standard fallacy indoctrination and regulations locking them in regardless of the problem of needed speed in face of pandemic.Do not overlook that we are a lot weaker on logic than we are on statistics and mathematical modelling, so we can set up impressive apparatus on weak logic. This reinforces gold standard fallacies. Then bring in politics and ego, multiplied by people whose ethics are weak and will do evil in the name of doing good. A perfect storm of chaos brews. Greed then is secondary, probably working through need to do latest greatest big payoff items to maximise shareholder returns. BTW, that is one good reason for tax incentive structures and community or state funded research institutes. That is what Dr Raoult heads. KFkairosfocus
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
08:10 AM
8
08
10
AM
PST
Support for the Oligarchs? Is that what is behind the attacks on HCQ This is repeated from the Frontline Doctors thread but is appropriate when discussing HCQ ---------- In an article on treating viruses
The Treatment of Viral Diseases: Has the Truth Been Suppressed for Decades? The COVID-19 pandemic is calling attention to the potential for treating viral diseases with currently available drugs, and exposing long-available but ignored research. The implications of all this are very disturbing. Where have the virologists been, and the CDC “experts” who claim to care about influenza deaths? Has the burgeoning nearly trilliondollar vaccine industry been built at the expense of patients’ lives?
the article considers a reason behind all the anti-HCQ hysteria. HCQ threatens the very large vaccine market. If a simple treatment can defeat the C19 virus could it or something similar also defeat the flu? Or any other virus disease? Even the common cold? We have been told for years that there is no treatment for the flu and similar viruses or the common cold except rest and our immune system. But would that all change if a simple treatment eliminated the need for a vaccine? https://bit.ly/3newztR Is it all about the money? Is it all about the power. Are those who oppose HCQ supporting the oligarchs in the drug industry and those in the technology industry. Trump by representing the little guy threatens them both and they represent a large percentage of the economy. Are all these dead just "dots?" See bit.ly/3aMWiC4 for Ferris wheel scene in the Third Man as Harry Lyme talks about the dead as dots as he makes money off of an ineffective vaccine. Is this what the anti HCQ people are defending? It appears so. One death is tragic, a million is a statistic.jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
07:38 AM
7
07
38
AM
PST
Nice rejoinder there, ET :PdaveS
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
07:21 AM
7
07
21
AM
PST
Trump is also on Remdesivir. If he gets better, what will they attribute it to. Odds of getting better without doing anything are about 20 to 1. I should probably qualify this since the survival odds by age group has gotten better over time. This probably reflects more people of each age group being tested and better treatment. Of course if he doesn’t get better, sell your stock in Gilead and Regeneron. The two drugs reflect two different ways of fighting a virus, antibodies and interference with replicating. See #12 above. Lot of high profile cases in Washington. Trump is by definition, high risk for C19jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
06:29 AM
6
06
29
AM
PST
Does anyone else find it odd that no prominent Democrats have had the virus but the list of Republicans goes on and on?
And yet one Democratic congresswoman had it months ago and HCQ saved her! HCQ saves a Democrat!!!ET
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
06:15 AM
6
06
15
AM
PST
Hydrogen peroxide is a disinfectant. And it has been administered intravenously for years for other diseases, like emphysema.ET
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
06:07 AM
6
06
07
AM
PST
I have been to restaurants and bars. I have been to crowded rallies. I only wear a mask when and where required- in grocery stores, for example. Maybe I am just lucky. Or maybe the prophylaxis is working. When Trump was on the hydroxychloroquine regiment he didn't get the virus. Just lucky?ET
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
06:02 AM
6
06
02
AM
PST
Isn’t HCQ just the poor man’s vehicle to deliver a load of zinc?
I’m not sure what is meant by “poor man’s version?” If there is a more effective way, I haven’t seen it. It is very cheap,, about 20 cents per pill in US a couple months ago. So a poor man could afford it. Apparently quercetin and egcg also work as an ionophere but not as effective but are easily available. HCQ requires a prescription in the US. These other iodophors are also very inexpensive and it is possible to take zinc and an ionophore in recommended dosages for about 15 cents a day. As Kf has noted HCQ has other mechanisms for thwarting the virus. See my comments above at #5 and #12.jerry
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
04:28 AM
4
04
28
AM
PST
AWS, no, it also has direct action, largely through being a weak base readily absorbed by cells. This interferes with several viral processes. See the marked up discussion based on Dr "Been" and the Frontline doctors, here in OP: https://uncommondescent.com/medicine/the-frontline-doctors-put-some-plausible-mechanisms-for-hydroxychloroquine-on-the-table/ That's why it is now very hard to dismiss efficacy cogently; a weak base is readily seen from chemistry, and the sorts of effects are readily plausible. Of course, such is not in the usual media narratives. Likewise the attempt to paint it a major toxic hazard is grossly exaggerating a basic fact the old pharmaco prof in my uni was fond of using to shock first year med students with -- pharmacology is the study of poisons in small doses. Even carrot juice, common salt, sugar and water can become toxic. KFkairosfocus
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
03:51 AM
3
03
51
AM
PST
Jerry at 33
There is zero evidence that the HCQ treatment with zinc is not effective.
Isn't HCQ just the poor man's vehicle to deliver a load of zinc?awstar
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
02:52 AM
2
02
52
AM
PST
F/N: Summary of treatment of Mr Trump (we can infer similar for Mrs Trump):
"Following PCR-confirmation of the President's diagnosis, as a precautionary measure he received a single 8 gram dose of Regeneron's polyclonal antibody cocktail. He completed the infusion without incident. In addition to the polyclonal antibodies, the President has been taking zinc, Vitamin D, famotidine, melatonin and a daily aspirin," Dr. Conley wrote in a letter released Friday afternoon. "As of this afternoon the President remains fatigued but in good spirits. He's being evaluated by a team of experts, and together we'll be making recommendations to the President and First Lady in regards to next steps."
In effect, similar to snake antivenin. Should work. He has evidently gone to Walter Reid out of the usual "abundance of caution" similar to Boris Johnson, and is expected to work from Presidential Offices there. (That is itself an interesting note.) KFkairosfocus
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
11:59 PM
11
11
59
PM
PST
MMT, the Ct value corresponds to viral load, i.e. concentration. It takes a certain critical mass to trigger actual significant symptoms and then the full blown U/L disease process leading to the second phase that is the main danger. Any test that detects viral load of that threshold level is a valid test for presence of the disease. The current argument is that the PCR protocol in use uses too many amplification cycles, leading to detection of small loads and remnants (some suggest, even from other viri) far below that threshold. It was also used to dismiss a test that is about 1/100th the cost, that could have easily become a daily test at home kit. That second test is effective a little below the critical viral load threshold, and would have been coupled to an early symptoms treatment regime that together would have rapidly suppressed spreading of the disease. BTW, if one is reinfected with a virus X, the immune system targets it and kills it off before its load gets to the threshold for that virus X, so immunity does not mean no infection but fighting it off before it is a problem. KFkairosfocus
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
11:38 PM
11
11
38
PM
PST
RH7, you can say "controversial" all you like . . . such now means little more than was publicly smeared and then locked out for failing to conform to the progressivist narrative partyline . . . the fact remains that she is one of the Frontline doctors who have put on the table a plausible causal model for efficacy, a model that is obviously hard to refute and which has been backed up by adequate performance as detected even in re-analysed hospitalisation statistics. KFkairosfocus
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
11:29 PM
11
11
29
PM
PST
Dr. Stella Immanuel, the controversial woman who claimed Hydroxychloroquine is the potential cure for Coronavirus, has lamented that President Donald Trump is being given some experimental antibody, which she described as ‘stupidness.’ She urged the president to immediately get on Hydroxychloroquine to get cured of Coronavirus. https://www.pmnewsnigeria.com/2020/10/03/trump-is-being-given-experimental-antibody-stupidness-dr-stella-immanuel/rhampton7
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
10:47 PM
10
10
47
PM
PST
News
Cease chortling, even if you think you are immune.
I wasn’t chortling, and I don’t think I am immune. But I do take precautions. I haven’t been inside a restaurant or bar since March. I wear a mask anytime I am inside a public space. What I don’t do is hold crowded rallies (not that anyone would show up :) ), or flaunt not wearing a mask as a virtue. Or encourage others to engage in these dangerous behaviors. Even your own Prime Minister engaged in social isolation before his wife got infected (back in the spring if my memory is correct), and isolated himself after she was infected. Trump was tested because Hicks tested positive. He received a positive diagnosis and rather than announce it immediately, he said that he was quarantining until the results came back. Why didn’t he announce it immediately?Mac McTavish
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
07:07 PM
7
07
07
PM
PST
KF
On Aug 9 you participated in a UD thread on the disease trajectory. Kindly look at it’s OP to see the order of mag viral load detection threshold issue:
I didn’t understand your point then, and I don’t understand it now. PCR is a very sensitive test but is very prone to sampling error (ie, false negatives). Antigen tests are much less sensitive but have an important role as a quick and inexpensive initial screening tool. If I understand you correctly, you are critical of PCR because it can test as positive at the very end of the virus running its course, or long before it can be a problem. But you also claim that for HCQ to be effective, it must be administered at the very beginning of infection. A stage that antigen may not be sensitive enough to detect.Mac McTavish
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
06:50 PM
6
06
50
PM
PST
For example, this is what Jerry said on July 11, 2020 at 11:41 am “There has been a known cure for over three months but the political spectrum in the US has prevented this cure from being used except in isolated cases. There are now more cures known but these too are prevented from being implemented. So a lot of dead people to make a political point. That is what people should be upset about. But the dead are just statistics till one wants to make a specious political argument.” https://uncommondescent.com/philosophy/covid-19-and-fading-respect-for-big-science/rhampton7
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
05:59 PM
5
05
59
PM
PST
Jerry, I repeatedly told you there was no cure and EVERY single time you refuted me. Go look at your posting history. It’s right there.rhampton7
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
05:51 PM
5
05
51
PM
PST
1 … 20 21 22 23 24