The Benefit of Arguments at UD
|August 11, 2016||Posted by William J Murray under Intelligent Design|
Probably one of the most daunting aspects of carrying on debates either about proper critical thinking, theism vs atheism, or intelligent design and its implications is the seeming implacable nature of those we debate here and elsewhere. It most often seems that no amount of logic, evidence or even reasonable discourse makes one iota of difference to our interlocutors; however, I think this is probably because most of those who will take the time to seek our position out and criticize it on its home turf are already fully committed against such positions, and are often emotionally entrenched.
Not only has my time here at UD aided in my personal transition from atheist to theist, I’d like to let the regulars here know that because of the information and arguments I found here, and after honing my understanding and my ability to deliver that information and those arguments through years of participation here, that time spent has had a nice payoff.
A few weeks ago my family and I were sitting in my living room talking one day when my adult granddaughter (mother of my great-granddaughter), who was either agnostic or an atheist, out of the blue asked me why I believed in god. I presented evidence and argument concerning cosmological fine-tuning, bio-semiotics and cellular nano-technology, and also first-cause and moral arguments. She was really interested, but didn’t say much at the time. Some time later my daughter informed me that she overheard my granddaughter telling her boyfriend that since that talk she now totally believes in god because of the information and argument I was able to provide due to many years of participation here.
Every once in a while it’s nice to be reminded that, sometimes, reason and evidence can actually get through to a person.