Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

I found the images of young people in “The Blasphemy Challenge” giving up their immortal souls on a dare disturbing enough to make me weep for them. I’m not rationally convinced we have immortal souls to give up but certainly the possibility exists. Imagine on judgement day that was you in the video and it was being replayed. There’s nothing to gain and everything to lose in this. Please join me in a simple prayer for the young victims of this stunt.

“Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.”

Comments
re: 47. kvwells No offense taken, kvwells, perhaps because I did not understand what you meant by "Trolling, are we?".realgm
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
10:56 PM
10
10
56
PM
PDT
@ 3. realgm concerning 21. kvwells I apologize realgm. An unthoughtful non-response on my part.kvwells
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
01:41 PM
1
01
41
PM
PDT
Consider adding your comments to the New York Times discussion of this matter: screens.blogs.nytimes.com Are these YouTubers damned? Can they be redeemed? And what is the status, for those who debate doctrine, of the Sin Against the Holy Ghost? Virginia Heffernan, The New York TimesVirginia
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
01:09 PM
1
01
09
PM
PDT
avocationist, This could be arranged, we'll see if each and every party is agreeable at the end.Inquisitive Brain
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
12:18 PM
12
12
18
PM
PDT
Hello Inquisitive, Realgm, and faithandshadow It's too bad, this could be interesting, but the email discussion won't be in a visible format for interested parties.avocationist
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
12:02 PM
12
12
02
PM
PDT
realgm, I think I was posting my comment when you offered to email. Thank you for the opportunity to correspond on this topic. I'll email you later today.Inquisitive Brain
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
11:02 AM
11
11
02
AM
PDT
avocationist,
He thinks eternal life is given or upheld forever by the power or will of God. And if you look carefully back over the many quotes that have been given in defense of our immortality with that understanding in mind, I think you will see his point. // Dec 21st 2006 at 2:18 am
Thank you for offering this helpful distinction. I definitely agree with that position. Scripture frequently states that immortality and eternal life is a gift from God. There is no disagreement about that. I think our pivot of discussion is where faithandshadow says that,
“people don’t have souls, they are souls.”
Perhaps I am reading too much into what faithandshadow is saying here. I take him to mean that the distinction between what Paul calls, “spirit, soul, and body,” in fact, does not exist. I see a failure to distinguish between the material and spiritual dimensions of humanity as abandoning Scriptural authority. Further, I claim that the material aspect of humanity is mortal, but that the spiritual aspect is the unique part given immortality. Am I reading you correctly, faithandshadow? And, are my claims unambiguously stated?Inquisitive Brain
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
10:56 AM
10
10
56
AM
PDT
This thread is not the best place to debate the "immortal" soul but I would be willing to continue the discussion with interested parties via email at gfmiller(at)CBmove(dot)com.realgm
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
10:51 AM
10
10
51
AM
PDT
Reply to #17 jb: I was raised in a fundamentalist Christian household, but once I left college I began to harbor my doubts that God was real. Without getting into too many details--it was shortly after questioning my beliefs that I suffered a number of setbacks and hardships. At the risk of glossing over too much, I'll just say that evil people did some evil things to me, for which I suffered immensely, and for which they were punished not at all. It was the usual route towards agnosticism: if there's a God in Heaven who cares about us, why do human beings often suffer as they do? So I started telling myself that religion was just a bunch of hoopla for simpletons and fools. Sometime later, I came across Dr. Hugh Ross's The Creator and the Cosmos, which I found intriguing. It was not much later that I started reading Dr. Dembski's work in ID. After that, I realized that there simply is NO plausible explanation for an ordered universe other than to say that some sort of guiding intelligence behind it all. I finally came to understand what the Psalmist wrote when he said, "The fool says in his heart there is no God."TerryL
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
10:08 AM
10
10
08
AM
PDT
Mike1962 Jesus was talking about the solders putting nails into his hands, who were mere underlings of the Roman power. Gimme a break, please. Given he suffered that and much more so these children could have eternal life I wonder if being shunned hurts any less?DaveScot
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
06:00 AM
6
06
00
AM
PDT
If the soul and body are destroyed, it could mean that they cease to exist. The soul of the rich man who ignored Lazarus was in Hell in Luke 16.tribune7
December 21, 2006
December
12
Dec
21
21
2006
04:14 AM
4
04
14
AM
PDT
What I think you folks who are defending eternal life do not realize, is that faithand shadow is not denying eternal life. Rather, he does not believe that a human soul posseses immortality on its own. He thinks eternal life is given or upheld forever by the power or will of God. And if you look carefully back over the many quotes that have been given in defense of our immortality with that understanding in mind, I think you will see his point. For example, the one about fearing the one who can destroy both body and soul in hell. If the soul and body are destroyed, it could mean that they cease to exist. Also, none of the quotes about how God gave life or created us in his image really show that the soul posseses immortality on its own, as an irremovable property. I'm not saying I believe that, but it is a position that I have seen well defended, scripturally.avocationist
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
11:18 PM
11
11
18
PM
PDT
Nevermind, I see you're responding to the original author.dodgingcars
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
10:19 PM
10
10
19
PM
PDT
mike1962, Who are you responding to?dodgingcars
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
10:18 PM
10
10
18
PM
PDT
Jesus was talking about the solders putting nails into his hands, who were mere underlings of the Roman power. Gimme a break, please.mike1962
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
09:09 PM
9
09
09
PM
PDT
Immortal soul? Well there are dozens of references to humans gaining "eternal life".. the most famous of these being John 3:16 John 3:16 "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.dodgingcars
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
07:15 PM
7
07
15
PM
PDT
faithandshadow, Thanks for the reply. The verse you speak of "God alone has immortality," is 1 Timothy 6:16. But that is simply one verse among many that deal with immortality. There are also many that identify a "spirit, soul, and body." Therefore, a Biblically-based view must take into account all of the applicable verses. Your apologia does not take all of them into account. But, looking at your logic with 1 Tim. 6:16, there are still problems. If "God alone has immortality," then how is it "given to the saints in the end." And if it is "given to the saints in the end" then it would not be the case that "God alone has immortality," and as I understand it, you are taking the meaning out of context.Inquisitive Brain
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
06:34 PM
6
06
34
PM
PDT
realmgm: "Dave, there is no mention anywhere in the Christian Bible of an immortal soul." Look at Revelation 21:
...I saw the the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God... Then I heard a loud voice call from the throne, 'Look, here God lives among human beings. He will make his home among them; they will be his people, and he will be their God, God-with-them. He will wipe away all tears from their eyes; there will be no more death, and no more mourning or sadness or pain. The world of the past has gone. ...I will give water from the well of life free to anybody who is thirsty... But the legacy for cowards, for those who break their word, or worship obscenities, for murderers and the sexually immoral, and for sorcerers, worshippers of false gods or any other sort of liars, is the second death in the burning lake of sulphur.
faithandshadow: "But what about Timothy who says God alone has immortality? Surely 'alone' excludes both angels and souls?" I think you're reading too much into it. While 1 Timothy 6:15 says:
...God...the King of kings and the Lord of lords, who alone is immortal...
This seems simply to be derived from Psalm 136:3:
Give thanks to the Lord of lords, for his faithful love endures forever.
j
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
06:31 PM
6
06
31
PM
PDT
Michaels7, That was a great essay, and I'm not easily impressed. DaveScot is a Christian. He just doesn't realize it yet. GilGilDodgen
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
06:16 PM
6
06
16
PM
PDT
Dave, Be careful.... you're walking toward the heart of Yeshua Ha Moshiach, Christ Annointed. A good direction, because he forgave a thief and those who killed him up until the last moment. It is one of the hardest paths to follow. Few of us merit such distinctions in this life and we're not the ones to know who, when or how one turns to redemption and cries out, "Father, Father..." In this vein, I agree at times with Operdeck. But I also recognize the Peters of this world, and John the Baptist thru to John the Beloved. We are called to pray for Dawkins, as well as the sheep he steers blindly away. For Dawkins and his crew, we have done the unpardonable sin in his estimation. Many here question either all or some of his own religion - Evolution, and his false Messiah, Darwin. Thus at first he tries to use logic, being a materialistic scientist, then he tries publicity, still trying to be mature, but eventually the basic instincts of him emerges, immature, and childish. He lashes out with venom like any child who does not get their way. His behavior is no better than others afterall. In fact, it is worse. It is one thing to make a joke, to deadpan, or add sarcasm to show how silly things are that people take so serious and themselves so serious at times..., at times. We can even laught at ourselves. But in this case, Dawkins is goes over the edge like so many before him. Having seen his god attacked, he attacks back. But many of us never realized he even had a god. We all thought he was a serious scientist based upon all the bravado. And yet, in his stone heart lives a god and a prophet. So, seeing his false prophet, Darwin attacked, and his religion, atheistic evolution attacked, he knee-jerks into attack mode himself. He fights back with his last weapon. Smearing his opponents, name calling, putdowns and the like, an all out effort to eliminate the enemy of his own god. Little does he know our God, his enemy. Our Lord does ask us to do exactly what you're instructing, pray for them. Reach out with love in fact. Within his simplistic reactions, you attack my god, I'll attack your God. Tit for Tat. He's not looking for truth, just reactionary vindictive slurs. I myself get caught up in the gunslinging. Your post helps to bring it all back into perspective. Yes, we should all pray for him and the children. Salvation being available for all people is the ultimate message of Christ. Neither science, nor law, nor works can grant it.Michaels7
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
05:34 PM
5
05
34
PM
PDT
"God is eternal, while angels, and the souls of men, are immortal." But what about Timothy who says God alone has immortality? Surely "alone" excludes both angels and souls? Gen 2:7: Man became a living soul (nephesh, same word for other animals.) (He wasn't given a soul, but became one.) RSV says, "Man became a living being." Eccl 12:7 is speaking about the spirit-a different hebrew word (the breath of life)-- and not a soul. A soul is what we are; The breath of God is the spirit or energy that animated all life. Gen 1:26-27;1 Cor 11:7; Col 3:10: We may reason and create like God; but God alone hath immortality. Mt 10:28--the word translated as soul here is Psuche, which can mean a number of different things, from life, appetite, emotion, etc. It does not denote some kind of immortality, which is given to the saints in the end. Well, I've run out of time. Yikes. But if I ever get back, I'll answer more of those. I have a response to every one of these versus. It takes some study, but the idea of an ethereal soul and man's immortality are pagan-influenced tradition.faithandshadow
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
04:23 PM
4
04
23
PM
PDT
faithandshadow and realgm, The first helpful distinction in this dialog about the nature of the soul is the difference between immortal and eternal. In Christian theological traditions I am familiar with, immortal means 'having no end', whereas eternal means 'having no beginning and no end'. God is eternal, while angels, and the souls of men, are immortal. If using the Christian Bible as an authority, one would acknowledge that man is a united material and spiritual being. With these distinctions in mind, below are a few verses. I have made an earnest attempt at concisely summarizing the salient passages, but please excuse the length and allow me to indulge: Soul created by God --- Gen 2:7; Eccl 12:7; Is 57:16; Zech 12:1 Made in God’s image --- Gen 1:26-27; 1 Cor 11:7; Col 3:10 Distinct from body --- Mt 10:28; Acts 2:27; 1 Thes 5:23; Heb 4:12 Soul subject to temptation --- 1 Pet. 2:11; 2 Pet. 2:14 The body is just a tent, or tabernacle, that does not last --- 2 Cor. 5:1-4; 2 Pet. 1:13 Soul departs body at death --- Gen 35:18; Eccl 12:7; Matt. 25:41, 46; Lk 12:20 Soul survives death of body --- Gen 35:18; 1 Sam 28:19; Is. 14:9-17, 1 Kings 17:22; Mt 10:28; Lk 8:55; 16:19-31 Committed to God’s care at death --- Ps 31:5; Acts 7:59; 1 Pet 4:19; 2 Cor. 5:8; Phil. 1:23; Rev.14:11,13 Souls of just in heaven --- Wis 3:1; Rev. 5:8; 6:9-11; 8:3; 14:13; 20:4 Jesus "preached to the spirits in prison" --- 1 Pet. 3:19 Nothing compensates for loss of soul --- Mt 16:26; Mk 8:36 Saving our souls --- Jms 1:21; 5:20; 1 Pet. 1:9Inquisitive Brain
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
03:46 PM
3
03
46
PM
PDT
Comparing God to the easter bunny and Santa shows the same level of maturity as these kids making these videos.faithandshadow
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
03:34 PM
3
03
34
PM
PDT
yea, i felt a little embarrassed by this. Personaly I put God and Jesus in the same category as the Easter Bunny and Santa, and I'd feel just as silly if I saw a bunch of youtube videos of kids saying they don't believe in Santa. I guarantee that most of those kids grew up in a fundy family and while their beliefs have changed, the way they act on professing their beliefs or lack of beliefs has remained the same.Fross
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
03:27 PM
3
03
27
PM
PDT
But I’ll remind anyone who is a Christian on this board that these poor folks CAN undo this Worth repeating. Prayers for the kids.tribune7
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
03:20 PM
3
03
20
PM
PDT
It's ironic because you have to actually believe in the Holy Spirit to Blaspheme the Holy Spirit in the passage from which they quote Jesus. Isn't it irrational and illogical to use such a false premise as the basis of their offer? So much for "Rational Response." God will be more than willing to forgive any of these people who do this YouTube thing to get a video. Christ is talking to people who actually believe in the Holy Spirit, not about people who deny one exists. That's a big difference, because how could atheists ever convert having denied that a Holy Spirit exists. Jesus here is angry with the Pharisees who have witnessed Christ's divinity through His miracle and is telling that applying the devil to the power of the Holy Spirit is blasphemy. You would have hoped that the RRS would have looked into it like rational human beings might do before making these kinds of claims!faithandshadow
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
02:15 PM
2
02
15
PM
PDT
Inquisitive Brain says, "There is frequent mention in the Christian Bible of an immortal soul." I disagree. In fact, the Bible teaches the exact opposite ... that "only God hath immortality. " (Somewhere in Timothy, I think.) Still, it would still be interesting to see what Bible passages you have in support of your view. I'm quite certain supposed support for an immortal soul is simply being read the wrong way, but I always like to get everything in. Additionally, people don't have souls, they are souls. (And man became a living soul. See Genesis.)faithandshadow
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
02:11 PM
2
02
11
PM
PDT
3. realgm Strange claim. Trolling, are we?kvwells
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
01:55 PM
1
01
55
PM
PDT
Collin: "dacook, I’d like to know what denomination you belong to if any. " I am a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. Commonly known as "Mormon."dacook
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
01:49 PM
1
01
49
PM
PDT
DaveScot I like the phrase "try it and see." There is an experiment that can be done that yields real results, but that is not empirically measurable. John 7:17 dacook, I'd like to know what denomination you belong to if any.Collin
December 20, 2006
December
12
Dec
20
20
2006
12:53 PM
12
12
53
PM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply